Whilst I agree that Grix offers more utility value, I think Tyke has comfortably the better form. Tough call as Grixy is a quality player.

Earlier this season I would most certainly have picked Grix but Tyke is in great form at the moment. Versatility versus the man in form. Tyke just edges it for me.

Tyke on form definetely. No time for the sympathy vote on missed opportunities, harsh on Grix but he didn't take his chance last week.

Ageed

Tyke. It really is a simple equation.

Think Grix is a better player but Tyke has been playing out of his skin of late. Tough call, I'd probably flip a coin. Grix is so underrated and comes up with some spectacular plays in all areas of the field, that sort of stuff can make the difference in a game like this, but Tyke's form warrants a place.

+1

Who says it is a choice between one or the other? How about both of them being in the 17?

I have thought of this. Monas and his suspect knees?

Drop Monas?! Blasphemy.

Sorry, I'll take myself off for an intensive sesion of self flagellation.