I absolutley love watching the Super League on sky , I look forward to it all week but for me the commentry is very poor at the moment we all agree on that. I am fed up with the biased thoughts of clarkey every game on sky Wigan Warriors practically always get mentioned he even said last week on sky Joel Monaghan scored two tries against US last year meaning wigan , Eddie is constantly getting all the players names wrong , surely this is one of the most important things he needs to get right.

The big one was last night at saints when he suggested the rhinos dying there hair for CHARITY has put them in the wrong frame of mind and is unproffesional which was totally uncalled for , Surely we should be happy that our game is getting involved in the charity.


Reckon there should be a re-shuffle on that side of things , I actually like Brian Carney he comes across very well and has actually played the game unlike eddie.

You have highlighted the fundamental flaw in Sky's structure. Hemming's role is to commentate on the games, summarising (stats, opinion, reviewing plays) is by the other party. Hemmings seemingly wants to cross both spheres, which leads to both parties talking over each other. The white noise is made worse when you factor in the additional summarisers. At best it is farcical, in reality it is rank amateur.

Id like to see Jon Wells given more of a role. Provides more insight then the rest put together, seem's to have a bit of bant as well.

That you can tell, when you watch any match he commentates.

He gets genuinely passionate, unlike the Sky muppets who just shout names, worn out slogans like T-R-Y and any 'controversial' (read: wrong) opinion to basically keep doing what they think Sky's coverage is 'renowned' for.

Sky has done so much for the game, and Eddie and Stevo I'm afraid must think they go hand in glove with all those good things. They don't.

I live in a college with 56 other lads and many don't watch RL. If I'm watching a game, casual observers just take the P155 at how idiotic the commentary is, I think it's fair to say it means a few of them don't take our sport seriously.

And don't get me started on Eddie's talent of naming players. Look at Friday, Joel goes in to score and we get 'MICHAEL MONAGHAN, MICHAEL MONAGHAAAAAN'.

End of a bell as are the rest of the 'team', with the exception of Carney and Wells really.

Banter? God forbid! Everyone is up in arms because Eddie said if you are going to read it do it properly...

i still say i'd be the ideal replacement for stevo!