I always liked him in Lovejoy, and thought he was excellent in Deadwood. Quality signing, should get bums on seats.

Getting on a bit now though. Still, he would fit in with some of our older players.

Always funny in hi-de-hi......

Big improvement over Higham/Clarke.

I'd take him at Wigan certainly.

thats cos you've got micky crap

Seriously, to sign McShane we would have to lose both Clarke and Higham, and Mick has at least 1 year on his contract. I really don't think he's worth going for, he wouldn't add anything to what we've got already.

Maybe as a replacement for Clarke if the price is right and theres nothing in the academy that looks to be ready in a year or two....

No he's should be in the England squad, and he's better than Monas and Roby..... Honest

If we're after a new hooker I don't know why we don't trey and buy Lincoln Withers from Crusaders, superb player who hasn't been snapped up yet! If we sign Withers or McShane personally I would sell Higham and keep Clarke as a hooker/second-row utility...

I'm fairly sure Withers is going to Hull KR and will replace Fisher.

McShane's a good player, but coming here he would still be second choice so I don't see what the value is for him. He's certainly a talent and deserves better than having to wait behind the ineffectual Buderus.