still can't belive atkins isn't in it.

I think Robys is getting a raw deal of many. He has been fantastic and he is the 2nd highest meter. I would have him and than Monaghan before Riddell. I know stats arent everything but there is a massive gulf between Roby and Riddell.

rlhttps://www.superleague.co.uk/statistics_player.php?hs1

I suppose if you ignore the fact that:

Roby has scored 6 times as many tries as Piggy
Roby has created 6 times as many tries as Piggy
Roby makes twice as many carries for over 1m per carry more than Piggy
Roby averages over 30% more tackles a game and misses fewer of them than Piggy
Roby makes 6 times more offloads as Piggy
Roby makes 4 times as many tackle busts as Piggy
Roby makes 4 times as many clean breaks as Piggy
Roby has kicked 40/20 and Piggy hasn't
Roby gives away fewer penalties than Piggy

then you have a great point there.

just a point oh saints fan, how much has roby actually played at hooker this year, i got the impression with cunningham and moore there this year, he's been playing a lot at 13.

He's played wing, centre, stand off, scrum half, hooker, second row and loose forward at some point this year, which just proves what a freakish player he is.

He's been phenomenal and any Wigan fan who thinks Riddell has had a better season is a bit deluded IMO - I'd bet there isn't a single Wigan fan who wouldn't rather have Roby or Monaghan in the team.