Thought I'd bring this back up.
Mathers has had some dodgy moments this season already with his mistake at Cas that led to a try, his mistake yesterday that could have been a whole lot worse and things like his pass to King infront of his sticks on his own 5... It's not great stuff to be honest, he gives his all and he means well but is he really good enough
He doesnt make many breaks and his strength coming away from his own line isnt the best, personally i dont feel he's good enough for us but we probably cant do much this season due to the salary cap limit but if were able to replace him next year then imo he should be second on the list for going behind Vinnie Anderson.
One day the team wont be able to make up for his mistakes and he'll cost us a game or two.