think they should give the job to this maguire then he can pick the wigan players ,reading the pie site this is what smiths done .other than thomkin can any wigan fan please tell me who is good enough .answer none.every wire player he picked stood up and did very well even bridge the lads got class and tuff with it .

Sorry, I probably didn't phrase that correctly. What I meant to say was that, given you think that 'dumbing down our own comp' would harm us at International level, don't you think that the sending our best players across to the NRL would have the same impact? We may end up with a couple of 'better' players, but as the overall standard of the SL would by definition be worse, the strength in depth would be compromised irrepairably. In other words we'd end up with a couple of decent players and a sea of dross.

At the risk of doubting the honesty of that post, can you name me a single 'pie' who considers Fielden or Coley to be international class, or think that Mossop is ready (not having made a first team shirt his own this season) or that Joel Tomkins had a good enough season last year to merit an England call-up? I'd love to have a discussion with these imaginary 'pies' of yours.

Touche! If that's the case I apologise. Couldn't supply me with the link by any chance...there's a thread I'd like to put my two cents on!

Edit: Just been back on the Wigan board and I still can't find it. Wouldn't mind that link if you will.