No

The ball was kicked off and no one touched it.
The ball was in the air over the touchline - the ball is still live.
The Cats player jumped with his feet off the ground out of play and palmed it towards the field - the ball is still live.
The ball never made it back into the field of play, it bounced out of play after being made dead by the Cats player.
Scrum Saints.

A top tip from the wise, before calling someone a fecktard get your facts straigh or you end up looking like one

Oh I do hope we meet you in the final at Wembley.

What a wonderful occassion to finally get one over on you

Totally bemused by this thread. I thought Thaler had an excellent game. My only complaints would be he could have called held during the two cases of fighting over a 50/50 ball and told the saints player to play the ball, but I think that's being a bit picky.

Anyone who regularly does any refereeing will know it's impossible to get everything 100% correct and it's definitely impossible to please both sets of fans, if either!

Saints won because they defended well, made few mistakes and played some good rugby. Catalans on the other hand missed too many tackles and made too many silly errors.

What do you expect?

If that happens, RL Fans will go into meltdown.