half the problem is we have a coach that does not know what his best 17 is and is trying to experiment when all this should have been done in pre season games

But we haven't made wholesale changes since the end of 2008 so it shouldn't be too difficult to come up with a best 17!

For all you who think Lowes Is Wrong to Drop Penny. Ask yourself this question.
If Penny was To stand And defend with on Foot to the left of His opposite Winger and never get sucked in would he ever be out of position to Tackle his opposite Number?

No he wouldn't but to continually do that he would be guilty of defending the field rather than defending by reacting to the play.

At least He wouldnt Be running From the Middle of the Field Trying to Stop Ade Gardner Getting in the Corner? He is his own worst enemy

And what exactly was Matt King doing when Pelo breezed in unchallenged on Saturday?

Well its basic Wing play to me

I want King on the wing. Preferably with another wing and a fuselage attached with the words 'Qantas' on the side.

So which one is better - Penny actually making a tackle, albeit sometimes going over the tryline with his opposite number or allowing him to get an offload away - or King, looking totally lost and not laying a finger on anyone?

I just think if you lpay on the wing you should stay on the wing. If matt king did that he wouldnt let anyone through

Jesus wept.

And if Penny did that they would waltz through the 10 metre gap between him and the rest of the defence (King mainly).