p**s take....not knocking the lad at all,but why have our own youngsters in the first team squad,when they dont get a sniff????

are our youngsters performing well enough in the reserves?

Adam is a great lad and a good young player with bags of potential, but as has been said does seam to be a kick in the teeth to some of our young lads, the u-20's haven't been fantastic up to now this year but equally they havent been poor. Quite suprised Ben Wood hasn't been given a chance rather than bringing in from elsewhere, maybe the coach just doesn't have the confidence in Wood, Spencer ect.

What has Jack Spencer done wrong ?
Sidlow was given the same treatment last year and the same thing seems to be happening to our other promising youngsters.
Maybe this is the way McRae works ?
It appears to have been sucessful with Sid, but it will not apply to all players.
Bringing in a player of similar experience to have a first team berth is certainly not the way to motivate players though.
Still out coach knows best

Not to sure about this move, we don't have any youngsters in the first team squad to play prop, think jack spencer is more a back row/loose forward so dont think thats a problem. However would of liked to bring in a player with a little more first team experience (yes understand availability and cost) possibly palasinea from wigan he's not playing regular at the moment or jordan james from crusaders or even luke burgess from leeds. Hopefully he will turn out like our other loan players (darrell goulding, stuart reardon) but i do admit we are in desperate need to beef our pack, if we can sort this out coupled with the way all our backs are playing we could sneak in to the top 8.

I cant understand the timing of the deal with no game this week and warrington next which he probably wont be able 2 play means we will only get 2 games out of him surly it would have been better to wait untill after the warrington game were we could get a full month out of him.

What has jack spencer done wrong, he couldnt break wind thats what hes only in there cause of the franchise rules stating you have to have so many salford based youngsters in the squad, neal has been training with the best prop in the league and one of the best he captained england will be a very good loan signing

maybe getting him now gives us time to get him used to our style of play, the loan could be a long term deal after the initial 1 mth?

Yeah it seems like that from the Simms quote on the reds site

I can appreciate the comments about overlooking our own young props but are they ready, are they good enough yet and do they have as much potential as this lad? It's one thing critising McRae but does anyone actually know if our own young props are better than this lad?

Also why should we automatically assume that McRae approached Warrington? For all we know he may have been offered to Salford because Warrington know of our front row injuries and they want to do the best for one of their players. Lets face it Warrington have a long line of fully fit quality props and first team opportunities must be very limited regardless of potential.

And lets not forget he's a Salford boy who wants to come and play for the club so why not give this loan move our full support rather than poo pooing everything McRae does.

Personally I think we'll see how good and how much character our own young props have by how they respond to this lad coming in on loan. If they sulk about it rather than rising to the challenge then they shouldn't be at the club in my opinion.

We are hardly blessed with props at reserve level so can understand why we've got someone in on loan. Got a couple of decent props in the under 18s side but not ready for the first team yet.

I'm lead to believe this guy is a Salford fan.... in which case he's likely to pull his tripe out for the cause. I say it's a good move.

he is a Salford fan born in Irlam great prospect bit of a work horse

hopefully he can step up to the mark

we have 3 on dual reg at Leigh, cooper has been at casleford and Penny is at quinns

Shows how things can change with new ground etc we were close to going bust not that many years ago

Good luck with new ground

Adam has really stepped up his game this season.. and its a fantastic opportunity for him. With ref to your younger lads, if you read the Leigh board about the dual registered lads over there, if anything it seems to have spurred the players around them to raise their game. Healthy competition within the team can only be good for your squad.
Harsh for the young lads in waiting, but a big lesson in life...

Spot on that