I bet he stands even further in when you visit Cas in a couple of weeks!
On a serious note, this is the issue with Carney, he can score tries others can't through brute force, but he concedes tries like a schoolboy.
Saw the highlights, you can only imagine that all the officials were looking somehwere else when the ball was dropped, it wasn't even subtle. Another example of why having video refs at certain games is unfair, had it been the your game on last night you would have an extra 2 points on the board.

As much as it pains me to say it... It seems we may all be wrong on the knock on incident.

Having watched this back a number of times... The ball is knocked out by Walne... So had this been on TV and gone to the screen, at best it would have been a penalty to Wigan in front of the sticks.

Therefore... probably losing the game anyway.

That's not to say the referee wasn't poor and give some dodgy decisions and Salford didn't deserve at least a draw from the game.

One of the worst refereeing displays I can remember, for both teams. It's a credit to both teams that they made it such an entertaining 80 minutes when Stokes seemed adamant on ruining it through his constant blowing.

I thought our first 40 was very disappointing, similarly to Widnes last week we gifted Wigan possession of the ball through our own mistakes. Flanagan losing the ball for their first try and then after a good set, instead of pinning them in their own 20 we're too slow in defence and allow them to the full length again. We made 3 or 4 great breaks in the first half and got nothing from them, whereas Wigan always had support options, we had none. (I accept the turnaround for this game was particularly short too).

I thought we improved second half and had a really good 15 minute spell, once we finally got over it looked like something had clicked.

Came away disappointed that we didn't get at least a point, but on the other hand I felt last night (and the previous two games) had shown me enough to suggest we will be challenging for a top 8 place this season. Thankfully the players have a decent rest ahead of them before Warrington next week, should be another cracker.

don't see it that way myself,you players hand was nowhere near the ball,blatant knock on that was missed by all the officials

Have a word with yourself you mentalist, there's video evidence to back it up. There's clearly a hand in at the PTB and the fact that the Salford players say nothing speaks volumes.

About time that Stokes got sacked he messes up week after week

Not likely to happen,as he has been promoted to be a full time official this season.

You have to question the judgement of the referees controller Ganson.

33 out of 100 by press at last weeks game at Leigh that needs some kind of looking at for a pro ref

There is no clear move to knock the ball out.If there was then it's a penalty then and there.Either way you look at it it's awful reffing.

No need to move the hand in to the ptb just leaving it there is a penalty.
If it had gone to the VR at best a penalty to Wigan and worst play on and the try awarded.

Well it looks like Mr Stokes performance has been rewarded this week with a nice weekend off.
Very well deserved

The Salford players did say things,also the post match interview by the coach had a mention of it being a knock on,all the press thought it was a knock on.Coincidence that the ref isn't reffing this week ?

Read Stuart Cummings article in Mondays League Weekly, he explains exactly what happened with the ptb. The referee was wrong on two counts in that incident.

In fairness both sets of fans agree that he had a shocker and so deserves to be dropped this week.

From looking at the reply, our guy was interfering with the ball so it should have been a pen to Wigan. They kick the goal and win