So much for sane comment...

Why do these types always appear when the team is at a low ebb? They never appear to congratulate or compliment when things are going right.

I'm not adverse to discussing the negatives at the moment, but it has to be done with some rationality and not come across as a ranting lunatic.

Noble was awful at Wigan. Couldn't believe he landed the job at Salford. I remember Wigan sneaking a win over Barrow in the cup. The played expansive rugby while Wigan looked clueless...and it took an injury to Smith before Tomkins got the chance he deserved. He has a mouth full of metaphors, but Noble is not the man to take SALFORD to glory.

got to agree with you there about lee as a neutral. on your games that have been televised he's been head and shoulders above some of the big name signings.

Have to disagree about S'au, in the second half yesterday when lots of the players were hiding he looked eager to take the ball in. Think anyone with a modicum of sense knows he's a bit underdone mainly because of the disrupted pre season with his partner so heavily pregnant but also the couple of injuries he's had in the game thus far.

Still think he will become a bit of a Salford legend as he seems like a genuine no nonsense player of the type we've been missing.

Michigan, for once I agree with you 100%.

Can I sign you up for the full VIP I love MR package? you get a spiffing badge and my likeness on a t shirt

I think if the entire team showed the eagerness of S'au and Tasi we would be much more competitive, I wonder if some are coasting? Can say if the Doc thinks they are then he'll have them up the road quicker than you can get out of the car park after the game.

Sa'u was giving his all on Friday, he genuinely put in 100%. I still don't think he's match fit and won't be for another 6 weeks yet, when we'll hopefully see the best from him.

rubber duckie is trolling you all with that argument about youth system, the same way that we got trolled when we first started to look like we had money. Fans from Saints, Wigan and so on told us we would never win trophies till we started bringing through youth.

Fortunately we brought through guys like Ratchford, Atkins, Myler, Hodgson and the Monaghans through from our Academy and three Challenge Cups followed.

S C, irony needs a lighter touch

trolling...complete tosh...my high esteem for you has just him rock bottom.

If you dont agree sally then that is all you need to say and for your information myler and ratchford came through the youth systems that we signed them from.
Salford and Widnes via Salford.
Doh....

Well said HB

Mullaney is kicking at around 68/69%, which is average to below average. Sneyd is at 95/96%, which is excellent — very high for Union standards. Compare that with the likes of say El Masri, Sinfield etc. (85%+), and Watkins (75%ish in his record breaking year), that's some going albeit early days.

Chris Hill is also another cracking product of the Warrington youth system.