i said he at least looked up for the cause,yes his defence isnt brilliant and as he the rookis he bound to get signalled out,just thought he made a few decent carrys and being a salford lad,thought he showed a lot more desire than a lot of the team!

I really do feel sorry for you supporters, despite being a Swinton lions fan I have a lot of mates who watch our number 1 super league side and quite honestly i am fed up of seeing them have their weekends spoilt by constant promises of a team purporting to be a top eight side.
Now you may not like this but perhaps not only do you need to get rid of messrs Simms and Mcrae but I would also suggest John Wilkinson should join them as well, since his tenure the team has only really had sucess when playing as a championship one club, after such a long period in charge surely he must see he has taken the club as far as he can.
Still light at the end of the tunnel, get yourselves down to the home of the Lions on Sunday and watch them put Oldham to the sword.You will get in for a fiver.

ssssssshhhhhh dont say owt but i heard we trained well all week

Your just a bitter Eccles bum, Jack has been Salfords leading meter maker in the last two games, just coz your massive conference side that got beat of us, pipe down you have nowt!!
Well in Jack keep it going lad!!!!!

An eccles bum? I don't play for eccles? Played there over 14 years ago as a lad, i played for Folly more recently 2003, and i admit Folly are the better club no doubt about it. so its not a biased view its an honest and imo truthful view of a player? I think i know the difference between a good player and an average joe, and Jack Spencer is average and in all honesty he wouldn't even be at salford if his farther wasn't one of the main academy coaches their.
It seems that its you who has the biased view, yes he's a salford lad but for a young lad to play first grade rugby they have to have something special in their game e.g Sam Burgess (strong runner breaks tackles and big hits), Kyle Eastmond (speed handling skills and kicking game) or Joe Westerman (strong defensive game and attacking game who can win games by himself for his team), Jack just doesn't have anywhere near the attributes of those young lads, and if i'm being perfectly honest why should we play young lads for the sake of it?
If there not up to the job its just going to weaken our squad and reduce our chances of success on the field. Thanks but no thanks Jack Spencer just isn't good enough he might try hard but i think even Paul Southern tried hard and look what success he brought us.

what a great post about the coach who doesnt look like a coach!!! i remember when he was at south sydney. it was exactly the same. hed turn up late do very little with the team. he might make a good manager but he doesnt look the sort of coach to be out there with a tracksuit on showing the boys tackling techniqies etc etc!!!!! they need a clean out, dont sack him and keep the job internally!!! WONT WORK

I would love to see what he teaches them in training especially tackling as we certainly dont no how to do that. We look so unfit its un true. Mcrae as to go to improve in all departments

Can't see the fitness being SM's fault, haven't just got ANOTHER greatest fitness conditioner? heard it numerous times that who we've brought in is getting the players fitter than they ever have been.

Hadn't got the heart to submit any comments last night. Even worse than I feared. I feel absolutely gutted over the situation facing our club in what should be a season of celebration.

I shall be looking eagerly each morning this week to see the headline we all deperately want MACRAE SACKED.

He was very unhappy to be taken off in the second half and replaced with Paleassina - he was right in front of us at the time, and you've got to give him credit for wanting to stay on the pitch at that point. Hope things improve for you soon, felt sorry for supporters and some of the players last night. Matty Smith looked gutted.

I'm afraid it is. As the head coach, he may have delegated the task but not the responsibility, that remains his.

Of course it is McRea's fault why their unfit. We were the last team back in pre-season training for starters, its his job to communicate with the assistants to lets them know what areas he wants the team to focus on fitness wise i.e weights, cardio, yoga.
Another absalutely stupid thing he does with the team is trains the forwards seperate from the backs? In what way will that benifit us no other SL clubs do that? All that i can see it doing is making the team gel alot less quickly. And one more thing? Does McRea know what dumbells are? Or maybe a bench press or a squad bar? Last night we looked like little school boys compares to saints and it showed in our defence.
We really need to bulk upalot more otherwise we'll continue having players making 3 yards max then getting tackled with ease like a load of rag dolls, again another thing that happened last night quite alot. Im sure i remember chris nero being huge at Huddersfield and Bradford? what has he been put on a low carb slimming diet here or something?

Sorry when a team of that quality is playing that bad its got to be the coach who gets the blame and ultimately gets the boot!

What bothers me is, most of the players don't actually looked bothered and look as if they have no motivation at all. It can't possibly get any worse than this.

Disorganised boys against organised men. Only one outcome!!

I thought the effort was there from several individuals, particularly Ratchford and Cashmere. Wild never stopped trying and Sidlow looked effective running wider up the right centre channel.

But without any signs of structure, organisation and tactics and without defensive organisation we were on a hiding to nothing. Why do we appear static on defence so the opposition have ten metres to play in? Why do we stand still on attack so that we have no forward momentum? Why do we defend our own line by standing a yard and a half from the line so that any attacker with forward momentum can score quite easily? Why do we wait until the twenty minute mark before bringing on our 'Impact' Prop when we needed him on after ten minutes before the game was lost for good? (even though he didn't make an impact!!) Why are the younger players with real potential not being developed as they should?

I could go on, but we all know the answer.

The players we have deserve better.

Perhaps the only questions left are 'Will he resign or will he be sacked?' and 'When?'

Two teams that play with pride and passion,all Salford 1st team players should be made to attend to witness total commitment.