You can't look past Dunnerman and Clinch for me, both had class and brilliant rugby brains.
Think as has been pointed out that Ratchford will go on to become one of the best half backs we've ever seen at the Willows. I just pray we can keep hold for some considerable time to come.

Don't think I've ever seen as many people agreeing on a thread on here before?!

Like almost everyone else I'd go with Clinch and Dunnemann, with Beverley on the bench perhaps, but sincerely hope that Ratchford will go on to be a better player for the Reds than any of those three.

IMHO our 'fall from grace' since the playoff appearance at Bradford has been largely due to a real quality half-back.

i have to agree with the majority on the thread and go with clinch and dunneman, i will put stefan ratchford in my half back of the next decade! lol

This has been the toughest of them all so far, I've been looking through my stats over the past week or so on all the positions but this one has got me quizzed!

Blakeley was great for his first few years in the 90's...but for me fell like Bambi if his sidestep didn't work.
Goulding was great...but he got up to his antics.
Holroyd was great (especially knocking over that Drop Goal against Wigan)...but at times looked disinterested.
Clinch was great...but mainly in NL1
Beverley was great...but again mainly in NL1 and didn't really reach the heights in SL.
Dunemann was great...but only for one year and only managed to cross the whitewash once in 27 games.
Robinson was great (at times)...but then he lied to our faces one evening (and he had this brilliant skill of finding the opposition full back with every kick).
Myler was great...but once again mainly in the lower league (although the early part of last season he was by far our best player and then...I don't need to add anything.)
Ratchford...is great and hopefully like SRAO has predicted he will become one of our finest EVER and he's got potential...but hasn't played enough yet.

There is a different version for each player but in keeping with the S.T. these days I’ll stick with the negative

So in conclusion!

I haven't got the foggiest but I'll suggest all of the above...for now!

One thing that really stands out for me is that not many of them had a great tactical kicking games but I digress....again.

Clinch and Dunnerman for me , they both got Salford somwhere we needed to be.
As for kicking games,the Willows has the strange effect of removing the kicking skills from the most talented of players who end up at Salford.

A kick is only as good as the chase but i do agree our kicking game does need a radical overall

I was gutted when Dunemann left Leeds. A great player. I was also a big fan of Clinch but was he ever as good for you lot as he was for Fax?

This

Myler and Dunneman