You give a player a chance of first team rugby or stay in the reserves, which would you take.
Steve Simms approaches Aussie clubs and we get the dross as we have now

That is what the majority of us have been saying this season(and last) glad to see you have seen the light

Not enough dodging or chucking for mine...

Firstly there is no place for personal abuse at the players, theya ren't going to improve because we call them all the names we can think of.

Secondly who would you drop?

For me there are 2 stand out players who aren't performing.Letting the ball bounce every week!

Like many say lets get Ratchford off the wing into the pivotal role.

Cashmere isn't pulling his weight presently, will more time actually make him tackle?

Who is fit? is Wilshere fit or is he just out of favour?

Lee Briers?

[sizepreparing to be shot down

Salford enquired about Lee Mossup to come on loan before the start of the season.

Wigan said they would consider it but later in the year. We are well blessed in the back row having Hock, Bailey, Tomkins, Hansen and O'Loughlin, so it could be good move for both clubs. Mossup is a superb young prospect.

The only problem may be that O'Carroll has a broken foot and will be out of action for 10 weeks, so Wigan may be reluctant to release a forward.

ITS SO SIMPLE ,,,, 80 PERCENT OF THE TEAM ARE NL1 STANDARD AND ADDED TO THE SQUAD ARE SOME OF MCRAES 2ND RATE AUSSIE MATES AND FEW OVER THE HILL SUPER LEAGUE PLAYERS..... SALFORD DIDN,T DOMINATE NL1 LIKE THEY SHOULD HAVE LAST SEASON ... 1ST TIME THEY MET S,LEAGIE OPPOSITION IN WAKEFIELD IN CC CUP WAS BUTCHERED AT HOME .... COME ON LADS ITS NOT ROCKET SCIENCE THERE JUST NOT GOOD ENOUGH .....

So what your more or less saying 'worldwidewarfare'

We write this season off now and start all over again in 2010 ?

and for the first time ever i actually agree with some of what he is saying

seccond that as well,

I just think we are not good enough, thought the wigan and saints game we were much better just don't think we are good enought YET

I don't think we should right the season off but learn from it we do have good players in our team sl standard they just need leadership, good coaching and good tactics

I think the players (Team) must now realise that their perfomances have been way short of what is needed and expected in Super League. The problem I see is that despite Mal's rally it isn't something that can be put right in a week or two.

At best if all the players really start to focus much more by putting in lots of extra training everyday, it will take at least a couple of months to see any real improvement on the pitch imo.

its 'write' not 'right' the season off....