Totally agree. He would of been a very decent signing about 4-5 years ago. Let's hope the days of signing other clubs aged cast-offs are a thing of the past.

To my reckoning we have a squad of 21 currently at the moment that being;

Evalds
BJB
Josh Griffin
Sau
Johnson
Dobson
Lee
Hauraki
Forster
J Walne
A Walne
Hood
Lannon
Wilkinson
Bibby
Bent
Wood
G.Griffin
D.Griffin
Menzies
MCB

So bring in another 8/9 we have a sizeable squad!

I agree to an extent.

But any Club signing anyone is signing that Clubs cast-offs, surely?

You bring a negative conatation to the term, after all, Scott Taylor was a Wigan cast-off.

Did you miss the aged bit?

(I'm not being sarcastic).

Sa'u, Griffin and Carney is like having 3 extra forwards in the pitch, God for a Gleeson of 10 years type centre outside Carney.

I seriously doubt Warrington are letting Monaghan go without knowing his best days are behind him.

I'd much rather find a younger winger we can help develop rather than one who's going to throw less and less good games from now on.

Do we even need wingers?

Yes I did.

Fingers got in before brain.

He made the wrong call,with a few others.

Joel Monaghan is not to be sniffed at, his try scoring rate is pretty much 1 in 1. We're also losing a fair chunk of experience in Hansen, Chase, Paterson, Maitua, Morley etc and therefore a character like Joel could be invaluable.

Disagree, would be terribly unimpressed if we signed him. Bringing in a high quality centre for me would be a much higher priority.

No offence, but if he does sign I'll take Sheens opinion overs MR. No doubt you'll want to convert this high quality centre into a loose-forward at some point next season too?