Quote: Bonita Red "Not quite the whole story.
There was no clamour for Gibson to be retained,and although JJ had a decent end to his Salford career,again it was felt we could do better eg the Walnes,MacPherson,Griffin and/or Rapira on the bench.
I don't think anybody's suggesting that Wigan and Cas are top of the league because of those 2.
Gaskell was offered terms to stay,but went.
Sneyd was part of the Rangi deal and will be coming back to us.
If the doctor had started the season with James and Gibson in the 19, it would have been said that we hadn't progressed.
Hindsight is wonderful but you're skewing the facts to suit your argument'"
I am not disagreeing with your post.I was just analyzing the recruitment and retention and how it has panned out.
It has to be hindsight because I tend not to make predictions and leave difficult tasks to the experts.
I don't think Julie Stott is a friend of the club - she assisted on the Malcolm Alker book,so may have a jaundiced view.
Hinting at unrest is the last thing the coaching staff need.
It never rains - it pours.