Quote: LincolnDEVILSFan "I never mentioned anything on how Wakefield was run as a club, but I did mean the same Wakefield that reached the play offs last season, the same Wakefield that lost TRONC, their best forward, and Brough, their best half back, and the same Wakefield that has stuck 30 plus points on us at their place for the past two seasons.
I agree you can't give any player vision or bottle. On the other hand you can make them stronger, to a certain degree you can make them quicker and you can improve their basic skills. Please don't quote dunneman back at me, but a large part of the reason we did well in 2006 was down to good basic skills and playing at tempo. One of the best Salford games I've ever seen was our home game against Saints that year, because we did the basics right and played with tempo. I know we lost but each half felt like it was 10 minutes long.
This is what John Kear can give a team. He will never take a club all the way to the top, but he will, however, turn a clubs fortunes round and is a very good short term fix. This is, also, what McRae doesn't give Salford. He hasn't proven himself worthy.'"
I'm not going to knock John Kear on here,plenty on the Wakey board do that.What I will say is that since they lost their two best players they have gone downhill.Your argument is that he should have been able to improve,strengthen and make quicker the players he had left instead of the poor team that turned out at the Willows.I maintain that you can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear.
Going back over old ground now but IMO our good season in 2006 was based on a good defence and good players. Yes I will quote Dunneman at you because IMO he was very underrated.He had a good defence and led us round the pitch,something we have lacked until Holdsworth started doing it just before his injury.
We also had Malc,probably at the peak of his career,Coley,Robinson,Rutgerson,Hodgson,Moule,Finnigan and Fitzy,who was a good fullback before his bad injury.McRae hasn't had players of this calibre to coach in his time at Salford.
I am not convinced McRae is the answer I just think he should be given a chance with the better players we have signed.