FORUMS FORUMS






RLFANS.COM
Celebrating
25 years service to
the Rugby League
Community!
  
FORUMS > The Virtual Terrace > Top Quality Decision
211 posts in 15 pages 
<<   PREV  NEXT   >>
Subscribe | Moderators: Admin, Durham Giant , TimperleySaint
RankPostsTeam
International Chairman14845No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Dec 200123 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Oct 2021Jul 2021LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
143_1357419061.jpg
:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_143.jpg



I agree with FA. Although we don't know the intent chances are he was trying to knock the ball out. But, he didn't and it was a clear red card offence - any other decision would have embarassed the sport on national TV.

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach1923No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Apr 200916 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Feb 2019Jan 2019LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
44920_1327005775.png
[quote="Harrigan":1th0f7ap]Wigan are the most structured team I have ever seen in this country.[/quote:1th0f7ap] [quote="NickyKiss":1th0f7ap]As a fan Wane makes you want to run through a brick wall so you can only imagine how he makes the players feel![/quote:1th0f7ap] [url=http://twitter.com/#!/theegw:1th0f7ap]@TheEGW[/url:1th0f7ap] [url=https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCsnX1esHN2wkEC1FxcO2TCg:1th0f7ap]YouTube Channel[/url:1th0f7ap]:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_44920.png



Quote: Khlav Kalash "Seems to be my understanding of it. Until the ball is grounded any offence will, as you say, be a penalty or penalty try, whereas when the ball has been grounded and a foul is committed then the 8 point try is awarded.'"

What this interpretation would mean was that a player who is punched unconscious and is prevented from scoring would receive a penalty, a player who is punched unconscious after the ball is grounded would also receive a penalty, but a player who is punched unconscious moments before the ball hits the ground, but who scores nonetheless, would not. I can't think of a logical reason why the RFL would require a penalty to be awarded to the player who has scored and been fouled but not the player who has been fouled and has scored, particularly when the difference in real terms is mere milliseconds. The infringement remains the same, as does the fact that a try has been scored.

If that truly was the intened implementation of the law the RFL would surely have used the word "grounded" instead of "grounding". I can honestly not think of a reason why the law would not explicitly state that the ball must be grounded in order to be eligible for a penalty if that really was the intention.

RankPostsTeam
Club Coach7911No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Jan 200520 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Nov 2012Aug 2012LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
12166.gif
:12166.gif



The problem lies in the timeframe

At what point is it deemed a try scoring act?

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach6268No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Oct 200519 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Jul 2015Jul 2015LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature

:



When the try is being scored. 4 foot in the air and, I cant remember exactly but 3 metres from where the ball was grounded isnt the try scoring act, albeit not far from

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach9680
JoinedServiceReputation
Jul 200915 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Nov 2024Oct 2024LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
46003_1489786199.png
:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_46003.png



Joel Tomkins dropping on Myler last year with the knees was a good few seconds after he had grounded the ball..... if we dont get an 8 point try for that one.... wigan CERTAINLY shouldn't get one when the foul was committed before the ball was grounded.

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach43No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Apr 201015 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Nov 2011Nov 2011LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
50966_1285853278.jpg
:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_50966.jpg



Quote: morleys_deckchair "Joel Tomkins dropping on Myler last year with the knees was a good few seconds after he had grounded the ball..... if we dont get an 8 point try for that one.... wigan CERTAINLY shouldn't get one when the foul was committed before the ball was grounded.'"

We didn't get one so you shouldn't....boo hoo....it shouldn't matter if the ball is grounded or not, whether it's before or after or whatever. A foul is a foul, dangerous play is dangerous play no matter where on the field or when during the game. Should've been a penalty. In effect Wigan were punished because they were about to maybe possibly potentially about to perhaps score a try.

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach13792
JoinedServiceReputation
Oct 200618 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Nov 2024Nov 2024LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
29100_1291104497.jpg
1/10:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_29100.jpg



Quote: TheElectricGlidingWarrior "What this interpretation would mean was that a player who is punched unconscious and is prevented from scoring would receive a penalty, a player who is punched unconscious after the ball is grounded would also receive a penalty, but a player who is punched unconscious moments before the ball hits the ground, but who scores nonetheless, would not. I can't think of a logical reason why the RFL would require a penalty to be awarded to the player who has scored and been fouled but not the player who has been fouled and has scored, particularly when the difference in real terms is mere milliseconds. The infringement remains the same, as does the fact that a try has been scored.

If that truly was the intened implementation of the law the RFL would surely have used the word "grounded" instead of "grounding". I can honestly not think of a reason why the law would not explicitly state that the ball must be grounded in order to be eligible for a penalty if that really was the intention.'"

I imagine if Tomkins had lost the ball when he was clocked then a penalty try would have been awarded.

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach9680
JoinedServiceReputation
Jul 200915 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Nov 2024Oct 2024LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
46003_1489786199.png
:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_46003.png



Quote: Toilet Doctor "We didn't get one so you shouldn't....boo hoo....it shouldn't matter if the ball is grounded or not, whether it's before or after or whatever. A foul is a foul, dangerous play is dangerous play no matter where on the field or when during the game. Should've been a penalty. In effect Wigan were punished because they were about to maybe possibly potentially about to perhaps score a try.'"


maybe if he hadn't of been knocked out, he would have dropped the ball and knocked on. eusa_whistle.gif

The player was injured in the process of raynor attempting to STOP the try from being scored.

it's no 8 point try by the letter of the law..... the Myler try on the other hand, was .... thats what i was pointing out boo hoo.

RankPostsTeam
International Board Member9982No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Feb 200322 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Aug 2015Aug 2015LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
4486_1428087820.png
Newsnight 13th May 2010: "With the role of Deputy Prime Minister a non-job. Has Nick Clegg gone from King Maker to tea maker????" I kept the faith and I kept voting Not for the iron fist but for the helping hand For theirs is a land with a wall around it And mine is a faith in my fellow man Theirs is a land of hope and glory Mine is the green field and the factory floor Theirs are the skies all dark with bombers And mine is the peace we knew Between the wars:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_4486.png



Quote: Khlav Kalash "I imagine if Tomkins had lost the ball when he was clocked then a penalty try would have been awarded.'"


If that is the case then there is no better argument for the rule to be clarified or changed.

I'm also in agreement with FA's post. Don't believe it was intentional, that doesn't mean it wasn't dangerous.

RankPostsTeam
International Star234No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
May 201114 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Jun 2011Jun 2011LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature

:



I was at the game and absolutely no one in the ground saw what happened. All anyone saw was Tomkins somehow sparked out.

It was only when it was replayed that the Wigan fans went nuts.

Would be interesting to know how the decision was arrived at. neither Ganson or the TJ's saw it happen and how can intent be established when the way the contact happened was not conclusive as to intent? Ganson could be heard saying direct contact with the head, and told Raynor it was unacceptable. Does this mean any head contact in a tackle or attempted tackle on now a red card?

Compelling game that Wigan won without ever clicking into top gear I felt.

Certainly it was a penalty try, because there was foul play, but a red card was the wrong decision IMO.

Makes me wonder how Leeds get a penalty try at Cardiff when a player does not even have the ball in his hands, but that incident wasn't considered worthy of one.

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach173No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Feb 201015 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Mar 2013Mar 2013LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature

:



Quote: morleys_deckchair "Joel Tomkins dropping on Myler last year with the knees was a good few seconds after he had grounded the ball..... if we dont get an 8 point try for that one.... wigan CERTAINLY shouldn't get one when the foul was committed before the ball was grounded.'"


Ryan Atkins did exactly that in Perpignan, and the ref Ian Smith gave them a penalty under the sticks after Bosc had converted the try giving them an 8 point try.

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach1923No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Apr 200916 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Feb 2019Jan 2019LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
44920_1327005775.png
[quote="Harrigan":1th0f7ap]Wigan are the most structured team I have ever seen in this country.[/quote:1th0f7ap] [quote="NickyKiss":1th0f7ap]As a fan Wane makes you want to run through a brick wall so you can only imagine how he makes the players feel![/quote:1th0f7ap] [url=http://twitter.com/#!/theegw:1th0f7ap]@TheEGW[/url:1th0f7ap] [url=https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCsnX1esHN2wkEC1FxcO2TCg:1th0f7ap]YouTube Channel[/url:1th0f7ap]:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_44920.png



Quote: Gahan "The problem lies in the timeframe

At what point is it deemed a try scoring act?'"

Quote: Gahan "When the try is being scored. 4 foot in the air and, I cant remember exactly but 3 metres from where the ball was grounded isnt the try scoring act, albeit not far from'"

First of all we must recognise a clear distinction between "try scoring act"/"grounding the ball" versus "having scored a try"/"grounded the ball". The laws utilise present tense phrases to indicate that the try is in the process of being scored rather than has been scored. If the laws were to use past tense words such as "grounded" or "scored" then we could assume that the ball must be grounded and, therefore, a try scored, before the law comes into play; the laws in fact use present tense to indicate that the try is in the process of [ibeing [/iscored but has not yet [ibeen [/icompleted, which would mean the ball is [ibeing [/igrounded, but hasn't yet [ibeen[/i grounded.

Granted, this still leaves some ambiguity regarding the point at which a try [ibegins[/i to be scored. On this point, however, I will respond to Dico, above, by posting the following two pictures, taken 0.24 seconds apart, which I believe show Sam Tomkins in the act of scoring (that is, having begun but not completed a try). The pictures show him a) to be in line with the try line when the foul is committed (not 4 feet in the air 3 metres away), and b) to have grounded the ball 0.24 seconds later. QED Tomkins was fouled in the act of scoring a try/grounding the ball and an 8 point try was required.

Exhibit A

Exhibit B


Oh, and Raynor was never, not in a million years, going for the ball.

RankPostsTeam
Moderator14324
JoinedServiceReputation
Dec 200123 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Nov 2024Oct 2024LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
27_1469093054.jpg
:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_27.jpg

Moderator


2 matches.

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach20628
JoinedServiceReputation
Mar 200916 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Aug 2016Aug 2016LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
44480_1390845286.jpg
It's been fun.:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_44480.jpg



Not an 8 point try, just because you're about to cross the line doesn't mean you'll score, look at Richards first disallowed try for example.

If he'd been punched after grounding it, then 8 point try

The only thing it would have been, at that distance, is a penalty try if Tomkins hadn't grounded it.

RankPostsTeam
Player Coach1466No
Team
Selected
JoinedServiceReputation
Aug 200816 years
OnlineLast PostLast Page
Oct 2013Jun 2013LINK
Milestone Posts
0
100
Milestone Years
0510 1520 2530
Location
Signature
40493_1265331809.jpg
:d7dc4b20b2c2dd7b76ac6eac29d5604e_40493.jpg



Quote: Horatio Yed "Not an 8 point try, just because you're about to cross the line doesn't mean you'll score, look at Richards first disallowed try for example.

If he'd been punched after grounding it, then 8 point try

The only thing it would have been, at that distance, is a penalty try if Tomkins hadn't grounded it.'"


The point is that he had begun the act of scoring then scored thus he was fouled in the act which should mean a penalty after the conversion.

211 posts in 15 pages 
<<   PREV  NEXT   >>
Subscribe | Moderators: Admin, Durham Giant , TimperleySaint
211 posts in 15 pages 
<<   PREV  NEXT   >>
Subscribe | Moderators: Admin, Durham Giant , TimperleySaint



All views expressed are those of the author and not necessarily those of the RLFANS.COM or its subsites.

Whilst every effort is made to ensure that news stories, articles and images are correct, we cannot be held responsible for errors. However, if you feel any material on this website is copyrighted or incorrect in any way please contact us using the link at the top of the page so we can remove it or negotiate copyright permission.

RLFANS.COM, the owners of this website, is not responsible for the content of its sub-sites or posts, please email the author of this sub-site or post if you feel you find an article offensive or of a choice nature that you disagree with.

Copyright 1999 - 2024 RLFANS.COM

You must be 18+ to gamble, for more information and for help with gambling issues see https://www.begambleaware.org/.



Please Support RLFANS.COM


4.44580078125:5
RLFANS Recent Posts
FORUM
LAST
POST
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
2m
Shopping list for 2025
RockNRolla
5532
3m
DoR - New Coach - Investor & Adam - New signings
al283
3877
3m
Game - Song Titles
Wanderer
40587
6m
Transfer Talk V5
Ex-Swarcliff
462
9m
BORED The Band Name Game
Wanderer
63077
11m
Film game
Wanderer
5313
16m
Season pass roll call
Ellam
23
17m
Rumours and signings v9
NickyKiss
28880
Recent
The Brick Stadium ownership update
jaws1
22
Recent
I dont think this is a good signing for the Leopards
Cokey
2
FORUM
LAST
VIEW
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
1m
Transfer Talk V5
Ex-Swarcliff
462
1m
Season pass roll call
Ellam
23
1m
Offiah on Salary Cap
Shifty Cat
11
1m
I dont think this is a good signing for the Leopards
Cokey
2
1m
Rumours and signings v9
NickyKiss
28880
3m
The Brick Stadium ownership update
jaws1
22
5m
2025 Proposed Rule Changes
YosemiteSam
18
5m
Hospitality packages including new refurbished Foxs Bar
Dunkirk Spir
8
5m
Garry Schofield
Or thane
13
5m
Guess whos backtrying anyway
Pumpetypump
5
FORUM
NEW
TOPICS
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
TODAY
I dont think this is a good signing for the Leopards
Cokey
2
TODAY
Red Devils sign International forward
Huddersfield
1
TODAY
Hospitality packages including new refurbished Foxs Bar
Dunkirk Spir
8
TODAY
Offiah on Salary Cap
Shifty Cat
11
TODAY
removing posts
Dannyboywt1
3
TODAY
Season pass roll call
Ellam
23
TODAY
Positivity Pact
Sebasteeno
3
TODAY
Jack Coventry
Wanderer
1
TODAY
A Year to Remember
Zig
1
TODAY
2025 Annual
JamieRobinso
1
TODAY
2025 KIT Thread
Sadfish
1
TODAY
NRL Kick Off Rules
stpatricks
7
TODAY
Garry Schofield
PopTart
6
TODAY
Out of contract 2025
Wires71
8
TODAY
Gary Schofield
Jake the Peg
9
TODAY
Joe Phillips
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Andy Ellis
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Manoa Wacokecoke
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Jeylan Hodgson
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Mackenzie Harman
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Ben Dent
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Callum Rutland
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Harry Aldous
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Jack Aldous
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Garry Schofield
Or thane
13
TODAY
Lennon Bursell
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Brett Ferres
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Reece Dean
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Alex Holdstock
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Thomas Minns
Wanderer
1
NEWS ITEMS
VIEWS
England Beat Samoa To Take Tes..
922
England's Women Demolish The W..
765
England Beat Samoa Comfortably..
1027
Operational Rules Tribunal –..
826
IMG-RFL club gradings released..
1102
Wakefield Trinity Win Champion..
1619
Hunslet Secure Promotion After..
1879
Trinity Into Play Off Final Af..
2134
Wigan Warriors Crowned Champio..
1708
York Valkyrie Win Back to Back..
1948
Hunslet Book Relegation Play O..
2413
Penrith Panthers Secure Fourth..
1852
Wigan Humiliate Leigh For Gran..
1943
Hull KR Survive Warrington Fig..
2123
Warrington Wolves Break Saints..
2259
POSTSONLINEREGISTRATIONSRECORD
19.64M 1,554 80,15414,103
LOGIN HERE
or REGISTER for more features!.

When you register you get access to the live match scores, live match chat and you can post in the discussions on the forums.
RLFANS Match Centre
There are currently no matches to display.
Matches on TV
This is an inplay table and live positions can change.
Mens Betfred Super League XXVIII ROUND : 1
 PLDFADIFFPTS
Wigan 29 768 338 430 48
Hull KR 29 731 344 387 44
Warrington 29 769 351 418 42
Leigh 29 580 442 138 33
Salford 28 556 561 -5 32
St.Helens 28 618 411 207 30
 
Catalans 27 475 427 48 30
Leeds 27 530 488 42 28
Huddersfield 27 468 658 -190 20
Castleford 27 425 735 -310 15
Hull FC 27 328 894 -566 6
LondonB 27 317 916 -599 6
This is an inplay table and live positions can change.
Betfred Championship 2024 ROUND : 1
 PLDFADIFFPTS
Wakefield 27 1032 275 757 52
Toulouse 26 765 388 377 37
Bradford 28 723 420 303 36
York 29 695 501 194 32
Widnes 27 561 502 59 29
Featherstone 27 634 525 109 28
 
Sheffield 26 626 526 100 28
Doncaster 26 498 619 -121 25
Halifax 26 509 650 -141 22
Batley 26 422 591 -169 22
Swinton 28 484 676 -192 20
Barrow 25 442 720 -278 19
Whitehaven 25 437 826 -389 18
Dewsbury 27 348 879 -531 4
Hunslet 1 6 10 -4 0
RLFANS Recent Posts
FORUM
LAST
POST
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
2m
Shopping list for 2025
RockNRolla
5532
3m
DoR - New Coach - Investor & Adam - New signings
al283
3877
3m
Game - Song Titles
Wanderer
40587
6m
Transfer Talk V5
Ex-Swarcliff
462
9m
BORED The Band Name Game
Wanderer
63077
11m
Film game
Wanderer
5313
16m
Season pass roll call
Ellam
23
17m
Rumours and signings v9
NickyKiss
28880
Recent
The Brick Stadium ownership update
jaws1
22
Recent
I dont think this is a good signing for the Leopards
Cokey
2
FORUM
LAST
VIEW
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
1m
Transfer Talk V5
Ex-Swarcliff
462
1m
Season pass roll call
Ellam
23
1m
Offiah on Salary Cap
Shifty Cat
11
1m
I dont think this is a good signing for the Leopards
Cokey
2
1m
Rumours and signings v9
NickyKiss
28880
3m
The Brick Stadium ownership update
jaws1
22
5m
2025 Proposed Rule Changes
YosemiteSam
18
5m
Hospitality packages including new refurbished Foxs Bar
Dunkirk Spir
8
5m
Garry Schofield
Or thane
13
5m
Guess whos backtrying anyway
Pumpetypump
5
FORUM
NEW
TOPICS
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
TODAY
I dont think this is a good signing for the Leopards
Cokey
2
TODAY
Red Devils sign International forward
Huddersfield
1
TODAY
Hospitality packages including new refurbished Foxs Bar
Dunkirk Spir
8
TODAY
Offiah on Salary Cap
Shifty Cat
11
TODAY
removing posts
Dannyboywt1
3
TODAY
Season pass roll call
Ellam
23
TODAY
Positivity Pact
Sebasteeno
3
TODAY
Jack Coventry
Wanderer
1
TODAY
A Year to Remember
Zig
1
TODAY
2025 Annual
JamieRobinso
1
TODAY
2025 KIT Thread
Sadfish
1
TODAY
NRL Kick Off Rules
stpatricks
7
TODAY
Garry Schofield
PopTart
6
TODAY
Out of contract 2025
Wires71
8
TODAY
Gary Schofield
Jake the Peg
9
TODAY
Joe Phillips
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Andy Ellis
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Manoa Wacokecoke
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Jeylan Hodgson
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Mackenzie Harman
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Ben Dent
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Callum Rutland
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Harry Aldous
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Jack Aldous
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Garry Schofield
Or thane
13
TODAY
Lennon Bursell
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Brett Ferres
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Reece Dean
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Alex Holdstock
Wanderer
1
TODAY
Thomas Minns
Wanderer
1
NEWS ITEMS
VIEWS
England Beat Samoa To Take Tes..
922
England's Women Demolish The W..
765
England Beat Samoa Comfortably..
1027
Operational Rules Tribunal –..
826
IMG-RFL club gradings released..
1102
Wakefield Trinity Win Champion..
1619
Hunslet Secure Promotion After..
1879
Trinity Into Play Off Final Af..
2134
Wigan Warriors Crowned Champio..
1708
York Valkyrie Win Back to Back..
1948
Hunslet Book Relegation Play O..
2413
Penrith Panthers Secure Fourth..
1852
Wigan Humiliate Leigh For Gran..
1943
Hull KR Survive Warrington Fig..
2123
Warrington Wolves Break Saints..
2259


Visit the RLFANS.COM SHOP
for more merchandise!