The referee has completely lost it now. What an utter joke.

looks like all you have to do is whinge about the referee after a game and you will be handed the next one on a silver platter!

sheens must a smug grin on his face today

Yessssss! Well in REED!!!

What an effort from Reed!

Inglis's local pie-shop must have closed down (how much weight has he lost?)

Watmough would have ate Widdop for breakfast.

Tom didn't need to step back inside, he'd ave scored direct.

Both commentators were telling us what a great new ref he was early in the first half.

Irrelevant - he still scored a perfectly good try and had it chalked off by this useless dingbat masquerading as a referee.

Useless play.

Why do we have players in position to receive the ball who then seem utterly shocked when it comes to them?

Hardly irrelevant.

The ref wouldn't have been able to rob him of the try if he'd have ran straight and hard.

I think the ref has done ok generally but you must question his understanding of what is and isn't held.

This guy needs to be

Sorry - my crystal ball is in for repair so I'm unable to view this alternate timeline. I'm therefore not able to see the clear-cut, easy, and utterly uncontroversial try you mention.

How was Yeaman "held" there?

Why are we allowing someone who took charge of their first top grade game in July referee a test match?

he wasn't!