i'm sure john kear keeps a closer eye on super league than edwards if that is what your basing your appointment on.

Kear would be a good choice, tactically sound and a modern day coach. Edwards is a good coach in a diiferent sport although he was a great player.

Don't want Noble as he won't bring on the younger players as has been proven, for example tomkins only got a chance at the expense of an overpaid aussie in smith and noble had no choice but to play him.

Wayne Bennett would be my choice but it isn't going to happen. If we want an overseas coach then someone like Graham Murray or Daniel Anderson would be my choice. Both have a great ability to get players playing "above" themselves, and are very good technically too.

If we go for a British coach then Brian McDermott and John Kear are the only real SL candidates. It wouldn't suprise me to see Hanly get the job, but I wouldn't like to see it.

why not?

in simple terms, not all great players make good coaches, we dont want JK either

i don't know...coaching st helens & doncaster to titles suggest he might have something about him

Hanley? Are you high? The guy hasn't got a clue on how to produce effective attacking football (there is a world of difference in quality between Tony Smith and Hanley before any idiot tries to mug that part of my post) and his ego gets in the way of his judgement.

tbh id be pretty happy with that choice........perhaps thats why we have seen him so prominently at all the england games!?!

I think they need to give up on the idea of getting a full time coach. What kind of coach wants to sac off their club career for a team that will play 5 matches next year, 2 of them meaningful, with a prospect of a third if they win one of the two meaningful ones.

Especially as the international game is seen as second prize to the club game worldwide.

No reasonable coach would want the job.

I think Hanley will be in the frame, i'm fairly non-plussed about this. I think the clamour to get 'Ex Pro's' back involved sometimes is a tad overrated, that said, there's not too many candidates jumping out is there.

I've actually a funny feeling that Justin Morgan might find himself in the frame also, he's always come across quite an ambitous bloke, and I think if the opportunity found itself at his door, he'd take it.

Do you really think he'd leave Hull KR?

Not sure.

Would he have to ?

He just comes across as somebody who's very driven. He's done alot in a short career, took opportunities when they've come along and has got a fair bit of experience in different cultures now, played in Australia, coached here, France, involved in the Wales setup etc.

It's just my opinion, if the opportunity presented itself, he'd be interested.

Agree with what you say, but a full-time coach would be dedicated solely to the national team or have I got that wrong?

I'm not sure what the crack is honestly.

You look at how Smith has juggled the last calendar year, it's certainly possible to combine roles. Morgan I guess, would just have to be keen to basically to go all year without a break, once the SL finished, he'd be off to Australia.

If nothing else, with the additional salary, he'd be able to get another couple of those 'cool' pinstripe suits.

Full time means does nothing else. That's what I understand the RFL want (but either won't get, or will get with a comedy coach)

we need a fulltime coach