Although we are being linked with him.

Not quite sure why Tom Briscoe is so highly rated.

Average, hard player. Boring to watch.

Well if he does go to you and you get the chance to see him week in week out then you will see why.

I've had the pleasure of watching him since he was 16 years old. He does plenty of highlight reel stuff but his real strength is his ability to carry the ball from the back. Unbelievably strong in collision for his size.

Believe me, he's far from that when he plays for you.

Top class player and fantastic to watch. He plays the game on the edge and its a pleasure to watch him getting stuck in to opposition forwards.

People talk about him in the same breath as Ryan Bailey but this lad isn't just a wind up merchant like Bailey who picks fights and runs away. He plays tough but fair (mostly) and he's more then willing to back up any talk.

He's a bit of a throw back in style and a game that seems to be getting a lot of its physicality taken away from it via the rule makers needs a player like McIlorum.

your right most utility players can't hold down a place because they are just solid and nothing else but Whiting is an intelligent footballer and stands out in every position, never gives a bad pass , dominates collisions offloads makes breaks scores tries and does it week in week out the complete player. I would have him in a Cas shirt in a nanosecond.

McIlorum ruins himself with poor discipline and how easy he loses his rag. I don't agree with the Sky hype when Roby, Clark, Henderson, Lunt, Hodgson, Monaghan, Houghton and Higham are all better hookers. As for Myler, his support play is very good, but it seems as though he doesn't do much aside from popping up on the end of breaks,

yes but he's a hooker, there needs to be more to his game if he wants to be a quality modern hooker. I don't want an England 9 being all about tackling and bashing people.

Richard Myler came up with 23 try assists this season and spent long periods of it out injured. Not bad for a player who "doesn't do much aside from popping up on the end of breaks" eh?

get a grip Myler.....now he is the most over rated player ever.....and Widdop don't make me laugh

We all know it's butter fingers Tomkins, so lets leave it there.

Change the title to:
Which player do you dislike?

Pointless thread

brough was rubbish again tonight!

Spot on. We've had more naturally gifted players at Hull in the last decade, but none who've played as consistently well as Whiting over such a long period and in such a range of positions. The poster who said he only fits in when others are injured is totally missing the point. He'll be the first name on the teamsheet every week, but is often the player moved to cover injuries purely because he's so good at stepping into a position that isn't his own at a moment's notice.

Jacob Miller

I knew a rovers fan would post one of the 17 Hull players after last night