Do You really believe that went backwards? he clearly stripped it and it went forward.

But i agree it hasn't had a real bearing on the result so far not like Brough's terrible performance.

Ish, it hit his thigh and did (using the line on the pitch) go backwards - but as I've said at numerous times I've no complaints of a knock on given when a player clearly loses the ball ...

I would of used Ferres (?) sheparding the dummy runner and stopping in defence looking for a penalty ... But thought that would be a little too controversial

Silverwood has been appalling tonight, but not as bad as the Giants.

Really bad performance from him, 5 forward passes, 2 blatant knock ons he only got 1 decision right for a forward pass.
Yet again inconsistent of calling held and moving off the mark at the play the ball on a positive note he wasn't as bad as the touch judges who don't see anything.

Of course you were there and near enough to comment on these decisions. And lets face it, it definitely wasn't the players who messing about around the PTB or trying to milk penalties and generally bend/break the rules. They were all "perfect" CONSISTANTLY

saints did what they had to, which was turn up and do the basics, they were pretty average and made to look briliant by a poor effort from huddersfield, even bradford would have beaten us last night!

Shush, Huddersfield were amazing. It's just that Saints were world class last night, that's why Huddersfield *looked* average.

That's what some saints fans I know said anyway. Deluded much?