Scott Quinell
Jonathon Davies

I am pretty sure there are plenty of half backs who could make great RL players, likewise forwards, fullbacks, centres, wingers. Only position they probably don't have is hooker.

No, we aren’t. I have provided evidence that we aren’t, where is yours that we are?
It isnt a reality We face, it is a reality we are creating. If well run, sensible and sustainable clubs are what you are after then set about creating well run, sensible and sustainable clubs. The SC doesn’t do this, there is no reason why Leeds being limited to spending about 12% of their turnover on wages and Wakefield spending about 60% of their turnover on wages helps either become well run, sensible or sustainable. Choosing a completely arbitrary number, and spending that amount on wages isn’t good business sense, its nonsense.

It can be good business sense to spend more, it can be good business sense to spend lots of money on a player. A club could easily recoup more than its outlay on a player like SBW in merchandising. Sponsorship etc. To do so would be good business sense. In this context the SC actively stops clubs from using good business sense.

me can afford what its owners are prepared to spend. The idea that the game can afford £1.6m for the past 10 years, and then slightly more in a year and slightly more after that and so on is complete nonsense. Some clubs can afford to spend much much more right now and still be well run and sustainable clubs. Some cant get close to what it is now, and wont be able to without massive input from their owners in the foreseeable future.

This SC in its current form simply doesn’t work, and wont ever work. It is obvious that that is the case. There is no reason why our tool for levelling out the league has to be related to wages. In fact it is infinitely preferable that it isn’t.

I don't recall us producing heaps more talented players before the advent of the salary cap, when was this?

Erm.... before the salary cap?

When exactly?? We've not won an ashes series in over 40 years, are you thinking back in the swinging 60s?

As long as I've watched the game we've been either gallant second in the world or worse. Often swapping between the two.

When Wigan outbid every other club for decent players and built the best side in the land I don't recall heaps more kids coming through than now. If anything I'd say clubs now are better run than ever before.

BTW I'm not against raising the salary cap, just against getting rid of it completely.

I never said clubs werent better run now than every before (in fact they would struggle to be run any worse Than the were immediately prior to SL. We did however, at that point have fewer overseas players and more british players in our league.

And I have no problem with us having some kind of levelling out levers. I just think there are plenty better, plenty which are more focused and flexible than an arbitrary wage limit.

Squad limits of 25 with a minimum of 15 which have come through your academy would stop a club buying up all the talent. The points system floated in Australia. A squad of 20 to fit under a £1.2m salary cap and 5 marquee players whose salaries don’t count as examples.

I'm all for some flexibility that rewards clubs that work the hardest to bring through young players (note I say work the hardest, not pay the most).

I'm not against allowing a kind of "cap free" idea for marquee players either, so long as we didn't go overboard. Maybe a maximum of two per club with the rest fitting under the normal limit, with the rules to be voted on every 2 years?

As it is I suspect some clubs already have ways around the cap to ensure players are paid by third parties unconnected to the club but known to a club owner. The RFL can only audit a club and not another individual or company.

I think the real key is to attract money into the game as a whole, for many clubs such flexibility is a dream. It's a bit of a chicken and egg situation, big money backers will come with a big profile game, but only international success will get that. But to get international success we need more kids playing the game and getting good coaching and coming through the system.

Jonathan Davies was a RU half back who played wing and centre in RL - Quinell struggled to get in a Wigan side.

In RL you need half backs to break the line and create things - that is the last thing you want in RU as you would lose the ball.

RL is a territorial game - RU is about keeping the ball the only thing they have in common is the shape of the ball and the first name. Centres and wingers play a similar game in attack but it is the defence where RU players would struggle.