if the video ref wasnt there, it still would have been given.

but the video ref was there,so it should be used.it clearly showed a knock on,so the try should have been ruled out.simple logic.
if leeds' try at bradford on good friday was ruled out for a knock on,so should carvells.the trouble is the lack of consistency.

Two wrongs make a right

No it wouldn't. Silverwood saw it clearly because he asked them to check it. Given the obvious level of doubt there is no way he would have given that back in the day before technology came along.

If there is any doubt (which there must have been given that he went to the video ref) a try should be given.

It was clearly a try.

I know this because three letters - T R Y - flashed up on the big screen and Warrington's score increased by four points.

I think you missed a comma

In the English language, that is a synonym for 'cheating'. Which should be removed from the game.

Are you using the word in some other way?

Or is it just, like 'knock on', another word you don't know the meaning of?

Hey … I'm just saying that I can only see two possible rulings that would allow the try to be given. Not making any comment on the validity of those rulings

Similar to how NFL style forward passes are ignored, or offsides at alsmot every play the ball.

Bizarre.

Saints fans are just ed cause a prop dicked all of your team for speed.

I can't imagine how vexed we would be if we had beaten a team only once in 30 odds meetings then.

Don't go claiming any records, Carvell's achievement was hardly a shock for us. Wayne McDonald once went on a 60 metre gallop with our pacy backline chasing slowly behind.

Rather than us being 'vexed' (I guess all the neutrals are just jealous of the Wire too?) is it not that you are slightly bitter about once more falling short in a should-win game against Saints? Forward passes killed us Nothing to do with a diminutive teenager tearing holes in your defense then or the fact your players once more gave up after 70 minutes?

100% knock on, video confirmed it time N time again, saints players walked out form behind the line in readiness to play on, no idea how they got a TRY for it... sure was a great try though, you could hear the "go on, go on, go on, go onnnnnn2 belowing out the southstand... I just stood there and thought "dont worry ade gardner is so fast he will nail him"...

Ganson needs arresting !