Is Charnley injured? I'd have taken him over Hall given his shape/lack of game time. Joe Burgess has been off form for a long time, Marshall and Grace too error prone

Hall fits the Bennett way, solid metre maker, decent defence and low error count

This basically in a nut shell. In the international game bringing the ball back and getting the team on the front foot is invaluable in tight arm wrestles.

Not the best defendant cover on the wing sure

However the steals and length of the field tries under his belt mean he was and is a weapon for any team

I usually agree with most things you say but you’re well off with your opinion of Charnley. He’s more than good enough. His try record is phenomenal and he’s been very good for us in his first season. He’d have scored 30 tries had he been next to a half decent centre. Fantastic winger.

both charnley and lineham have been excellent, tom's probably first name on the team sheet for me.

Yep. Both in better 'form' than Hall.

Hall is a great winger still, and does the basics well. He’s great in the air, superb carrying the ball away from his line and is a great finisher.

While he might not be express pace or a match winner, but if we don’t win the series, it won’t be because of Hall.

I always found Charnley didn't look so effective at international level.

He’s Bang average at club level too. Been completely outplayed by every half decent winger in SL

Candidate for the most ridiculous post of the year. I wouldn't claim that Charnley is the best winger in SL but very few opposition wingers have 'outplayed' him.

LeBron chatting rubbish shocker.