Totally agree with this. If you reset the points then teams that have grafted hard and are at the top are essentially punished for their hard work while teams at the bottom of the 8 will essentially be given a helping hand to compete with the top teams. Awarding the shield after the 23 is what I would propose so that teams wouldn't take their foot off the gas after they are secure in the 8.

yep it worked in the past but not now

That would be the Premiership you're thinking of. Although the format changed a couple of times over the years, this was just an end of season playoff with the only prize being a separate trophy. The League champions were the team that finished top after the regular season in those days.

rlhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rugby_League_Premiershiprl

What I hadn't realised was that from 1907 to 1973, the championship was decided by a top-4 playoff - just like we have now, albeit with the extra nuance of the split after 23 games.

I challenge you to find a quote on this forum from a Hull fan stating what you have just suggested.

IIRC Lee Radford said something has to be done because teams in 7th & 8th had nothing to play for after the split. He was not exactly suggesting the points be reset but I wonder if he is still of the same opinion?

One way of doing it would be make the top team after the regular rounds champions whilst the super 8s is turned into a different cup competition.

The odd thing, and of course i am speaking from the position of being a Wigan fan cue boo's and hisses, is this.......

Hull, Warrington and Cats are all playing some good rugby.... By popular consent, we are playing really badly.... But somehow, we are not off the pace, except in points difference... End of season will be very interesting.

Seasons of false dawns does that to a person.......keep the faith.

Have you got a link to the interview please?

So you find it strange that Catalans don't get as many votes?

Hull's record vs other 3 top 4 teams
vs Catalan 2-0
vs Wigan 1-1 (but Hull win on points aggregate)
vs Warrington 1-0 up with one to play


Warrington's record
vs Catalan 1-0 up with 1 to play
vs Wigan 2-0
vs Hull 1-0 down with 1 to play

Wigan's record
vs Hull 1-1
vs Warrington 0-2
vs Catalan 1-0 up with 1 to play


Catalan have lost every game against these opponents

Do you still think it's strange?

He's doing a good job of ignoring the fact he embarrassed himself on here the other day

I'm going for a Hull F.C. v Warrington final.

If Cas could somehow get into the top four they would be my dark horses.

As for nine people voting for Wakefield - Really .

Quote: Mild mannered Janitor "I challenge you to find a quote on this forum from a Hull fan stating what you have just suggested.'" forums.rlfans.com/viewtopic.php?f=34&t=587248 How about this thread from the Hull board with some suggesting resetting the points? Also suggestions of 1st starting on 4 pts, 2nd on 3 pts, 3rd on 2 pts, 4th on 1 pt and 5th-8th on 0 pts.

Quote: Mild mannered Janitor "I challenge you to find a quote on this forum from a Hull fan stating what you have just suggested.'" forums.rlfans.com/viewtopic.php?f=34&t=587248 How about this thread from the Hull board with some suggesting resetting the points? Also suggestions of 1st starting on 4 pts, 2nd on 3 pts, 3rd on 2 pts, 4th on 1 pt and 5th-8th on 0 pts.

I believe it was an interview pre season. I know I didn't imagine it because I was of the same opinion and felt rather dirty agreeing with him