L'Estrange grounded the ball after Silverwood blew the whistle. I've checked the rule book and cannot see how you can award a try scored after play has stopped.
No ask Stuart Cummins available this year?

Actually he blew before L'Estrange grounded it , I've just forced myself to rewatch it, even eddie who hates the Crusaders commented on it but as they say its history now

Ah, Phil Clarke, the man who once saidand[/i it was only the third game of the season, I'll look forward to better things and live with what we got.

I disagree. If there had been no video the ref would have had to make the call. All he has to do is make the same call. It might be right or might be wrong, just like any other decision made by countless referees up and down the land; we all have a cheer/moan and get on with the game. He's just deciding whether, or not, someone scored in a rugby match, not starting world war three.

The Schifcofske try was a perfect example of why benefit of the doubt should go to the defending team. When they replayed the L'Estrange try you could hear Silverwood blow his whistle before L'Estrange crossed the line, so why he then went for the video ref I have no idea.

No he didn't, the audio which was played to the VR clearly shows that the whistle was not blown before the ball was grounded but immediately after.

I think you mean "Isn't it great we now have two Welsh clubs in the pro ranks?"

Is this an anti Bradford thread or what?

Quote: Starbug " You obviously struggle to believe that figure Starbug, have a look at this picture and you'll see what the cameras didn't show (i.e. fourth and most populated stand) as they are at the top of it. www.footballstadiumguide.co.uk/i ... xham02.jpg 2600 not great by any means but certainly believable when you see the full picture not what others tell you (something you advocate yourself I believe)

Quote: Starbug " You obviously struggle to believe that figure Starbug, have a look at this picture and you'll see what the cameras didn't show (i.e. fourth and most populated stand) as they are at the top of it. www.footballstadiumguide.co.uk/i ... xham02.jpg 2600 not great by any means but certainly believable when you see the full picture not what others tell you (something you advocate yourself I believe)

Try of the season, yet you're all whingeing. Maybe you missed it

Hardly the try of the season, the away stand was in total silence until Silverwood went to the big screen, maybe they missed it too? I think Raynors "try" for Leeds at the Millenium Magic got more of a reaction. But what do I know

If you think that defence is the key aspect of the game then I suggest you may be watching the wrong game.

Rugby League is primarily about scoring TRIES and rewarding the effort for doing so.

Your posts get more and more ridiculous.

If your more interested in seeing people ' defend ' , watch football

RL is one of the few games that you cannot play ' defensibly ' , that's why I watch it