Or is that you are just a knee jerk reactionist?

Not really. He was woeful last week. It would have been better if he wasn't there.

He still has more charm and charisma in his little finger than Agar has in his whole body.

Sinfield is one of the most talented players in SL, I don't know why you feel the need to bad mouth him.

I made a comment about his media skills on one particular day. They were shocking. Most people are agreeing. Those that aren't agreeing are defending him as a player (which isn't exactly disagreeing) and it is totally against the point I'm making.

I have not made one negative comment on this thread about his playing skills because I respect him as a player (in fact, I have said that in this thread). Why you feel the need to bring Agar into this I haven't a clue?

Why can't people actually discuss the point being made on this forum?

Is there one?

Yes.

The OP saw one SL player give a not particularly inspiring performance on the SL Show and decided to start a thread about it. Presumably having watched numerous other players and coaches with the charisma of a waxwork of John Major bore the pants off the audience most other weeks but not really caring about those for some reason.

Still no better on the website.

Finally, someone gets it. I didn't think it was that difficult. Thank you, Andy.


I rarely watch Boots N All these days because I don't have Sky. And I only occasionally catch SLS (don't have a TV recorder so if I miss it, I miss it!). Most of the time you get someone like Iestyn Harris, Brian Noble or John Kear who have good media skills. Rob Burrow isn't too bad either.

Who is the last player to be on SLS? And who was the last person to be on that put in as poor an effort as Sinfield the other week? I don't doubt that there is someone, but it's been a while.