Definitely not.

I'm intregued at some peoples views on this subject, this is not me forcing an opinion i'm just interested where other are getting their opions from...

Not hacking it week in week out in the NRL? Why? He has one of the best records for remaining injury free and turning out week after week, what makes you think the he'll be any different down under? He the best prop (maybe player) in the Saints squad, a squad containing Josh Perry.

On what basis do people think he'll get home sick, has he showed this trait before?

Why does showing passion translate to 'spitting his dummy out'? And do big Tongans and Samoans have swords in the NRL because i saw a Big Kiwi in a pink shirt take the full force of Graham's dummy good friday.

Now this is my opinion...

He'll quickly become a highly reguarded export, his home fans will love him, the opposition fans will dispise him, he'll wind people up, he'll get targeted- but like he has always done he'll get back up. He'll develop massively, he'll be captain of England within 24 months.

I did read that one, why are people only giving him a year before he's back, what makes him different than other English guys that have gone down there and made a name for themselves, eg Morley, Ellis, Burgess?

They were/are better players.

And appear not to spit the dummy as much as he does.

I don't ever recall Burgess being named international prop of the year, has Morley, renowed for losing his cool (spitting his dummy out?), ever won man of steel, nope... but no your right

You know i really thought you were about to come back with a well formed arguement then, an argument that would test my opinion and give other board members something to chew, but no - what a shame, same old unfounded rubbish that has gone before

I don't see it as a 50/50 split. Not at all. And youth development has been sacrificed before. It might be cost effective in the long run, but club chairman are notoriously fickle when it comes to anything other than the here and now.

You fail to back any of your assertions up with evidence.

His performances in the past 2 seasons clearly illustrate he is a quality player who will do well in the NRL. I wonder if you actually watch the NRL as you seem to have a rather odd opinion of Graham's likely performances in the competition. You also have to remember he will be a member of a tough Bulldogs pack which will offer him decent support.

Couldn't agree more mate.

He is just a wind up merchant with time to spare,troll of the highest order.

anyone that doubts grahams quality as a top class prop is a bit of an idiot.

Barry is certainly one of them.

if he doesnt fry over there, like a hamster in a microwave.... he will be one of the best props in the NRL.

So you think he might get away with spitting his dummy because when some big Tongan threatens to remove his head the Bulldogs pack will step in?