He over ran the ball, his feet were out of play before he took a tumble

God the level of delusion in St Helens is strong this year

And the feet first from Marsh during Morgan’s second try. Also thought there were Fozzard style high knees from Wellington before Whitley’s try too ...

I think as this thread is proving, Saints were never onto a winner on this one. I think the “I’m sick of talking about Ben Barba” from the commentary team summed it up.

Are you completely devoid of any sense? You clearly can’t read as I said he chose to play for a penalty by throwing himself to the ground. Anyone with any sense would realise that’s because he felt he couldn’t get to the ball so therefore played for a penalty (he could have got to it if he’d just ran to the ball).

So he could get to the ball but he decided he couldn't based on it sitting up perfectly in the in goal...ok then. I presume you know he felt he couldn't get to it based on him telling you.

I agree that earlier in this thread people were laying it on thick with saying everything was against Widnes when it clearly wasn't but Peryoux clearly put a hand on Heremaia. Trying to say the Widnes player chose to dive is pathetic.

As a Saints fan I would happily agree to that. I think what others are trying to say is that Heremaia made the most of the contact as he had over run the ball (and that’s why it should never even have been talked about as a penalty try) but the contact meant it was always going to be a yellow.

The most disappointing thing for me is we have an exciting young talent in Richardson whose really coming into his own in an area England are desperate for a superstar in and he barely gets a mention with all the ref scrutiny again

One of two things happened, either, Heremaia thinks he can’t get the ball so throws himself to the ground to play for a penalty or he falls by accident. Either way, there is no contact and he falls over the dead ball line. Peyroux didn’t help himself because he made no attempt to go for the ball either but that doesn’t change the fact there was no contact at all. I’ve got no complaints with the refereeing decisions though as we did get a fair bit of luck but the anti-saints agenda some have is frustrating. The commentating today was so one sided it was a joke.

Sthelens win. So Leeds fans like theprinter go into meltdown. Wow. Embarassing. Calm down junior it’s only one game!

Regards

King James

Yep discussing an incident from a game and giving an opinion is "a meltdown" weak trolling

Yes I,m quite surprised with "The Printer" usually a good poster but a bit off kilter these days.

Why? Because imo something was a foul and the referee agreed.

Fozzard style forearm from LMS that went unpunished when he raised his arm/elbow and ted the young widnes kid, Watts got sent off last year for less against Wigan and it was that dirty barsteward MM whom most agreed deserved what he got for reckless coming in as he did.

I,m talking about your general posts and not the one match incident today.

What's the problem?

Just watched the replay this afternoon the Marsh incident on Morgan should have been a penalty try. The right knee of Marsh goes straight into the neck and lower jaw of Morgan, hope the disciplinary pick it up, but it will probably end up as a caution.