Quote: the artist "this is a decent point, are players simply too heavy nowadays to have a decent step with speed? perhaps the obsession with size has resulted in less mobility off the mark and in tight spaces.
also in times gone by, did the 5m rule at the ptb mean the no.s 6 and 7 needed the step developing just simply to avoid decapitation from an onrushing forward?'"
The mid air 'step' that Johnson does and a few others before him is great for tiring defenses (ask Kevin Sinfield) and in close 1/4s can either look amazing or gets you KTFO if an opposing forward doesn't fall for it or one comes in to blindside you (generally the latter as a lot of forwards are too slow of thought to even figure out that players like SJ 90% of the time step in the same direction)
I think even the smaller backs are relying more on outright pace and change of direction/body swerve as opposed to a classic side step as this hasn't really being coached for years by the looks of things and probably doesn't come naturally to many players anyway.
Escare has a small full flight step which with his pace is effective, I remember Gareth Raynor's 95m try against Joey Johns' Warrington side and he did one at not far shy of full chat & nearly fell over, still managed to bamboozle the Warry defence and two of their players clattered into each other but it shows that even someone of Raynors size who was about 14.5 stone found it hard to do at real pace.
Most of the succesful clubs have got very good mobile forwards with lots of pace and a decent change of direction.Peter Gentle tried bringing this in at Hull & was ridiculed for it
As for the halves needing to be elusive, they certainly did, the refs let a hell of a lot of high/late tackles go with barely a flicker or even a penalty. A penalty was a small price to pay for taking out your opponents playmaker though and most coaches would be instructing their hitman to do exctly that. I remember Topliss getting ted really badly in 82 or 83 CC semi final in the first few minutes and the ref played on for the first one, 2nd one the Cas player (might have being J.Joyner) properly facked him and toppo stayed down..touchie came on and the ref gave a penalty, not even a warning IIRC.
That's how it was for halves in the 70s/80s, dunno about the before that (i didn't start going to games until I was 9 in '7icon_cool.gif but I expect it was just as uncompromising if not more so...certainly there were a few hardmen of yesteryear that would batter some of the handbag swingers we see now.