What a random post.

Talk out your , Lyon was class, newlove should have been great but could not be d, see Kevin iro. Senior easily the best centre in super league history, Lyon may well be considered a better player but two seasons over 15+

Yep

Leeds sure have a higher block of flats.

There surely can be no doubt Lyon is the best super league centre of all time, if only for 2 seasons. He guy was and is class, what a player. As good as senior was he's no Lyon. And moon again top top class, better than Watkins in my view, but a fair few steps below Lyon

Meninga? Lyon was (and still is) a terrific player, though.

He didn't play in SL though.

What utter nonsense. Just because a player didn't play for the "mighty" saints doesn't mean they can't have any ability. Your talking about a player who played over 350 SL games and yet averaged over a try every other game. You may also remember he won three SL titles in a row against a certain side.

He did plenty of things better than those players as they are three completely different centres.

He was undoubtedly quicker than either Newlove or Lyon and a better broken field runner. He may not have been as skillful as either but he's certainly in the top couple of SL centres. Senior also played (at a consistent level) in SL for *five* times as many seasons as Lyon.

Don't get me wrong Lyon is a fantastic player but this billing of him as some greatest ever SL player is just silly, its entirely biased by his performances in the NRL. Why don't we just rate Andrew Johns or Alfie Langer as SL's greatest players...

Also, senior could throw a better punch than either of the players

Sorry I just can't take this thread seriously... 4 pages on SL's greatest centre and Stuart Littler hasn't had a mention?icon_wink.gif

I'm gonna p1ss a lot of West Yorkshire off here but I just never got the whole Senior thing, I just think it's a sad indictment of the dearth of quality centres in SL to be discussing Senior as a "great". Probably would have found 10 Aussie centres in the same period that were better than Senior. Not a wind up btw, I just think he was vastly overrated!

Senior was a stand out player in some very very good Leeds teams. Clearly that was just down to luck

Joel Moon is OK, but there is rarely a game that goes by when I don't wish Leeds still had Keith Senior. Alright he wasn't Brad Godden, but he was Leeds second best centre of the past 20 years and has still not been adequately replaced.

Senior was easily Leeds' best centre since Schofield, in fact at his best he was one of the best centres this country has ever produced. It's a shame more footage doesn't exist of the first 5 years of 21st century RL on YouTube because I think some people are forgetting just how good he was during that period. He was the best centre in the world for about 3 or 4 years. IIRC he was selected in the world XIII a few times as well.

He was a good player no doubt.

Those World XIII teams (he was picked three times) would have a lot more credibility if the Judges that decided the votes were clearly named.
They always seem to be a shadowy bunch of mainly English magazine editors with a handful of Australians that write articles in their magazines.

His tally of tries against the Aussies of 3 from 15 games is poor IMO

To be fair, I wonder who *does* have a good tally of tries against the Aussies.

Moon is one of the best centres in the league at the minute, which shows the regression in quality in that position.

Lyon was the best of a group including Gleeson, Senior, Ha'pe etc.

Sadly, Moon is up against Gelling, Turner and Shenton. Not the same kind of test

Moon is very hit & miss

Can come up with moments of pure genius then other times looks as poor as poor can be