He was stood in front of the play the ball which is classed offside if he takes part in that play at anytime.So that was actually one of the few correct calls made tonight TBH.

Ah fair enough. Still think Rovers have been hard done by. Green missed a sitter though.

Right team won in the end thankfully, a good to watch.

Yeah, missed the last 3 mins though to catch a train! Doh!

I'm assuming for the one in the first half with the kick he judged that because a hull kr hand touched the ball facing forward, simultaneously as it touched a hullfc hand, it rendered it a knock on even though it was the hull fc hand that propelled it away.

I'm assuming that the 'ball steal' one in the second half he judged the hull kr player was losing control/lost control therefore the hull fc player was entitled to take the ball as although it was resting on the body of the hull kr player, it was loose.

the 3rd one was a stonewaller, offside at play the ball.

That one in the first half was actually touched by Hall before Whiting.

There were some very difficult decision for the video ref tonight, but actually I think they got them just about right. The shoulder charge was a little harsh, we deserved to concede for putting on such a pi55 poor last tackle play, but again if you're going to apply the rules properly then it is the right call. The Caro offside one isn't even up for debate, and the ball steal over the line was really tough to call. Although as someone already mentioned the ref thought it was lost and he had a good view of it. The two contentious decisions in the game were Bowden's try, which I thought was a forward pass, and the drop goal, which was never touched.

I can't have any arguments with the result anyway. Best team won. We didn't even deserve a point tbh.

I laughed a lot during the game. The best one being a forward pass call by the fans before the ball had left the players hands.
I also notice that in all the moans no one has castigated Costigan for his 6 second blunder that allowed Hull to score or was that a match official fault?
It was also evident that a lot of people were upset by the non try that Caro was involved in. I do believe the laws of the game are available at a reasonable price.
Enjoyed the game even allowing for the thuggish and interference element that both teams wanted to bring to the game.

That's why I like rugby league!!

If you don't like it maybe a bit of touch rugby is more to your liking?

You will struggle to find one as it didn't happen. Hull never scored off the back of that.

why not have a competition for the worst video ref or are they all has bad

how ironic the only replay to clearly show whiting didnt touch the ball last night was after they ruled he had and awarded a dropout!

Karma.

Karma.