What are your thought's on the matter when Lee Briers flicked the 'V' to the Leeds fans in a play off game only two years ago?

No? I thought not.

Tomkins was wrong, but if you was him and you were booed for wearing an England shirt with pride, would it not be possible for you to forget your status and public icon figure for a moment whilst caught up in the heat and passion of probably rugby leagues most passionate contest and maybe vent your anger/protests towards them?

I don't condone it but surely some people can see why he's done it?

People need to stop clutching at straws and get over it quickly!

As far as I could tell Danny McGuire was at the middle of it, good player with a bad attitude.

So the reason leeds couldn't get over the wigan line is because they had a get out of jail card? Nothing to do with wigan having great defence and aptitude to hold on to a narrow lead! Wigan never went behind in the game so we can't say that we had a get out of jail card at all! The leuluai try was clearly a try, there was no gap between ball and arm, benefit of the doubt was the correct call, the only call leeds can feel aggrieved about is the kick which went off charnley, however wigan would have had leeds in a great position!

And abblett made no attempt to regain his feet and made no attempt to play the ball,should ha have been a wigan penalty every day of the week!

Anyway I've had enough of debate! The super league and challenge cup are both covered in cherry and white ribbons and not blue and amber! That is all that matters to me! Wigan are back and the rest of the rl world don't like it!

Oooh nice and bitter.

Poor officiating, all the bad calls went to Wigan and unfortunately for Leeds they resulted in scores. I watched the replays of Hicks and he was looking DIRECTLY at the ball and surely (unless he is incompetent, blind or had money on Wigan) he must have seen it come off the Wigan player.

The RFL could not have chose a worse game to put Hick and Childs in front of the nation.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but a player has to play at the ball in order to concede a scrum.

]
To clear this up, it was the 2006 playoff game, incidentally when Briers was a lot younger, brasher and generally more distasteful than his mellower present day incarnation.

Hopefully Tomkins will follow a similar route in his career. Sure he was an idiot, but he's young, brash and can come across as distasteful, but we all make mistakes. Give him a fine, make him publically apologise (although hopefully he will do this off his own back when he realises how foolish he was) and hopefully he will learn with age and experience.

If not, then maybe an Aussie hard man will change his mind... "What are your thought's on the matter when Lee Briers flicked the 'V' to the Leeds fans in a play off game only two years ago?'"

Yup, pretty much how I saw it too.

Since when has deliberately diving/sliding towards the ball to gather it not been seen as playing for it?! Yes I agree it came off Charnley before going out, but if we're using your logic Burrows attempt to get the ball hit it into Charnley's legs before going into touch so it would still have been Wigan head and feed.

Another berk who answers his own question and then when corrected turns to puerile abuse. The point most people are making is that Tomkins did this on national, terrestrial TV. I don't think it's worth a ban but the fact that he hasn't even apologised yet is appalling, and I'm surprised given Maguire's reputation as a disciplinarian that he hasn't seen to it that Tomkins does do so. We need to keep this type of stuff out of our game as it's one of the many things that makes wendyball such a feeble spectacle most of the time.

So Because Briers was on Sky is doesn't matter? Did Briers apologise? Was your coach at the time not a disciplinarian?

Another y berk who answers his own question and then when someone points out a similar incident in the past, they retort to all the Wigan hating.

Pathetic y jealous scum.