Tomkins is a natural full back, best one we have had for a long long time.

Isn't Widdop being groomed as a number 6 at Melbourne? I'd seriously consider moving him there and playing Robinson at 7.

We lack direction, organisation and structure. Plus the kicking game is dire!!

How can you drop Shenton and not Atkins? Also carrying a winger on the bench?

Atkins looks a complete nuffy at this level. What's his strength supposed to be? His haircut?


I think his running game is potentially an outstanding facet at this level. But that will never be fulfilled if he is the only playmaker, which he sort of seemed to be today. If he moves to fullback, the team still needs somebody else to take pressure off him. It's a pity Sinfield (at hooker) and Eastmond can't play. I'm learning just how much of a difference they can make by their absence.

Atkins is never an international centre.
Everytime I bring it up I get shot down in flames when, in reality, its been as plain as day to anyone who knows what to look for all year.