He has got to be the worst forward along with Phil Adamson to ever have played for Saints,even worse than Ricky Bibey.

Beat me to it

If big Keef wasnt there to defend Lauaki I reckon Burrow would have leathered him

why?
maybe cos no one has said Bailey yet

has to be Les Boyd, closely followed by Tuuta, Paul Round and Tallis

No it isn't.

Warrington fan, are you?

Tallis wasn't dirty, just hard. Watch his fight with Terry O'Connor, was an absolute cracker.

With the videos around these days its impossible to build up a dirty play CV like the old timers had - anyone who tried would soon be out of the game. So in a blast from the past

Len Casey.

Specialised in cheap off the ball hits on the oppositions half backs because they were smaller. He filled his pants when he did it to Fred Ah Koui though and copped a hammering back.

Your other top thugs like Boyd, Mills, Reilly, David Watkinson, Eric Hughes, Mick George,etc took on anybody.

Casey was just a low piece of dirt.

He landed a few beauties thats for sure

Paul Davidson.
Terry Newton.
Jamie Bloem.

And of the lot running round nowadays, I'd say Ben Westwood.

I feel insulted that TMFMISL has not been mentioned!

Kurt Sorensen.

Alan Rathbone wasn't shy when it came to a bit of bif.

Surprised no-one has mentioned Jason Hooper. An expert at shoulder charging kickers off the ball.

Quite ironic that he had to retire due to a shoulder injury.