This is not really 'All Time' since I never saw the likes of Jim Sullivan, Billy Batten, Harold Wagstaff, Nat Silcock, etc etc.

But anyway, based on players I've actually seen in the flesh, I'd select:

1. Jonathan Davies

2. Billy Boston
3. Joe Lydon
4. Neil Fox
5. Martin Offiah

6. Tony Myler
7. Alex Murphy

8. Kevin Ward
9. Keiron Cunningham
10. Andy Platt
11. Bill Ramsey
12. Vinty Karalius
13. Ellery Hanley

It'll probably change tomorrow when I have a few "how could I have forgotten whatsisname" moments.

1. Kris Radlinski.
2. Jason Robinson.
3. Gary Schofield.
4. Neil Fox.
5. Martin Offiah.
6. Roger Millward.
7. Shaun Edwards.
8. Adrian Morley.
9. Kieron Cunningham.
10. Lee Crooks.
11. Phil Lowe.
12. Bill Ashurst.
13. Mal Reilly.
14. Paul Newlove.
15. Ellery Hanley.
16. Paul Sculthorpe.
17. James Graham.

No, the biggest disgrace was that Arnie 'Boxer' Walker wasn't selected ahead of either of them as he was better than both of them, he just played for an unfashionable team. Same applied to Billy Pattinson at loose foward.

I'd agree that Walker was better than Nash and on a par with Reg.