Saints fan per chance? I think Graham is a great player but the recent daft stuff has let him down. Should have had a yellow card for the GF outburst imo.

The senior player ? More so than O'Loughlin or Ellis ?

As for tantrums when the ref has been wrong, the point is that in all my years of watching RL I have never seen a referee change a decision based on a player throwing a tantrum over it. Refs make wrong calls all the time, some go your way and some don't. You accept the good and the bad and just get on with it, Graham has an inherent inability to do so judging by his often OTT reactions. Not good captaincy material in my view.

doubt that anyone in that team can match the levels of passion he will display.

Is that really the direction you want our sport to go in?

Captaincy is how he inspires those around him. He is clearly better at that than most. When Saints should have been going through a horrendous rebuilding phase like Wigan and Bradford did he (Along with KC) lifted the club on his broad shoulders and carried it for 3 or 4 years.

O'Loughlin is another candidate. McBanana and his cronies clearly didn't feel he was the right man. They will know which player carries the most respect amongst the group and gone with that man. That man is Graham. Ellis isn't a big enough character to be a captain, he's too quiet.

also got experience of captaining a succesful England team on tour in Australia.

Good appointment really. Of course the wigan fans will be disapointed that Sean O Loughlin wasnt named captain but do we really need another Andy Farrell type captain? One who will just stand there with his hands on his hips, staring into space everytime the aussies score a try?

Players like Jammer, Morley and peacock are the type of players you need as captain.

Could there also be the possibility that O'Loughlin isn't in the starting 13?

Murphy and Tommy Bishop used to question calls and so did Hanley... In fact Hanley was once dismissed for dissent. Would you doubt [i their[/i leadership?

An absolute no brainer to me - Graham was the natural choice and can actually string a sentence together. If everyone can muster the same pride and energy that he exhibits then that will be a good start.

watch the england captain curse strike him down.......

Throwing tantrums isnt showing passion (although i do think he is passionate and inspirational with his play and work rate). Football fans mistake shouting at referees for being passionate when it is not. RL does not need to go down that road.

If every England player approached the game with the same attitude "problems" as Jammer, we wouldn't have copped so many hidings in recent years.

Automatic pick in the team, one of the more experienced players in the side despite his age and leads by example. Good choice.

Interesting appointment, i would have thought SOL was ahead of him, but could be just what england and he needs, the responsibility might calm down the whinging that has crept into his game. He's Englands best forward, and has the required passion, possibly a great move by mcbanana

What is the England captain curse?

EDIT: Oh, you mean Peacock and Morley? Is that all?

O'Loughlin lost the captaincy of Wigan as soon as they got a decent coach, what makes him good enought to captain England?