Still, any RL fan with a brain would swap any of them for Greg Inglis. Coming out with daft statements doesn't make you more of a fan mate. Like saying "I know we did really well with Sheasy at left back an won the league. but I wish we didn't sign Paddy Evra".

Carmonts does a hell of a lot for the club though, like I said, young players learn from him and he's a father figure, im not doubting Inglis maybe technically better, but who's to say he would come over here with the right attitude and contribute more than Carmont? Carmont has been up there with the best iv personally seen at Wigan.

I fully understand why you're fond of him, but anytime you can improve a part of your team so greatly it would have to be done. I'd swap any of our centres for Inglis(apart from Blythe).

I agree, my point though is that any signing is a risk, no matter how good they are, and with Carmont, he has proved over the last few years that he is reliable solid, classy and rarely makes mistakes, with a new signing these things arent guarenteed so id be hesistant to take the risk, il take Inglis though and stick him on the other side

Be telling me you wouldn't swap McIlorum for Cam Smith next.

Could be next season, all depends on signings really, the debate still goes on about whether Leuluai will go to 9 and we may sign a half back. Id personally prefer Leuluai at 7 and McIlorum alternating with someone (L.Tomkins or a signing) next season.

Joe Mellor at 6?

That was what I was hoping, or a least a few run outs next season as we still have Finch, but from what I hear off regular U20's goers since he's injury he's lost a yard of pace and his kicking game has been very poor.

Were you used as a medical guinea pig for hallucinogenic drugs?