no promotion.........but when a team is clearly dominating the championship year on year then and only then should that team be considered to be moved up if they should wish to be......

as i said every year we've had different winners of the championship and every year we have morons screaming they should be promoted...all we'd be doing is replacing like with like...instead of incresing the quality of the top division..

and my criteria for my super league is the 9 teams that i feel would produce the best,most consistant and intense RL games............plus london

At long last, we get a chance to talk about Promotion/Relegation and the make up of Super League on the VT!

have featherstone dominated the championship? they've only won it once!

Are you talking about the league, which they HAVE dominated, or the play off final ???

i'm talking about it as a whole....when a team dominates the championship,wins it 3 or 4 times on the trot and can clearly prove they are too good and too big for the championship....move them up!


as for why i've kept london in...do you know over the 17 years of SL they've averaged a league position of 8th....never finished bottom and only finished next too bottom twice.....thats why they make my 10 team super league!

They've only won the grand final once but have finished the top of the table for the last 3 years

so??? winning the grand final is what counts......and actually only winning 1 grand final after finishing top for 3 years proves they are missing something and are'nt the dominant club some of you think they are..

Not really, it means thay aren't that good in 'one off' cup games. FYI over the past 3 seasons their league record reads, P54, W47, L5, D2, F2259, A1036.

If we're going on one off games, then maybe they should replace Cas?

champions are decided by winning the grand final.......hth

He has completely gone against his own arguement.
Fev have dominated the CC and in most other sports they would be promoted, perhaps their time will come ??
BTW, are things settling down for you at Odsal and do you think that you will be competetive next season ?

So you suggest promote the ' team ' , not the club , and the main criteria for that team is winning a one off game? , sounds like yearly promotion to me

Nice one !
You will be waiting for a long, long time to find a more dominant team than Fev in the CC.
A club winning a play off series (3 or 4 games at the end of the season, should be regarded as lucky, not dominant.
A club that finishes top of the pile 3 years on the bounce IS dominant.

Why is a club which won the qualifying comp better than the club which won the actual comp?