If it did work I'd be in favour of it. The evidence in a small number of clubs dominating over here and Melbourne in Oz indicates otherwise.

nope you said you were in favour of a percentage based cap which doesnt even the competetion.

now you are making a silly argument that melbourne dominate the NRL.

keep shifting those goal posts.

they are heavy, eventually youll stop.

average crowds have been rising in the nrl.

a big part of that is that one team doesnt dominate.

from a purely selfish point of view, if we stick with the SC in its current form, Leeds will bee picking up their 7th title in 7 years in 5 years time,

but with my altruistic hat on, hopefully before then we have a rethink and put in place rules to force clubs to do what we want them to do, and forget this idiotic notion that how much you spend automatically makes you successful,

Just one last thing, you do understand Leeds didnt spend the full cap last year dont you?

and bradford have done a poor job keeping them

wigan have the 2nd highest crowds in the league and they havent won a comp. since 1998

its about marketing.

if you need to keep winning the title to keep crowds at an acceptable level then your marketing is s**t.

aaverage crowds have been rising in the SL, yet Leeds have won 3 out of the last 5,

wanna bet on that?

money for jam

what odds would you give me

leeds crowds have peaked.

unless they fix headingly even if they keep winning they wont be growing their crowds much or helping the average to rise,

if say huddersfield or hull won it, they would add probably 5000 to their averages overnight.

thats why if every club could win it, you would get much greater crowd growth

odds?

looks like ive won this little debate then!

have you done any kind of research on this or evidece for it, or like everything else, just pulled it out of your ass

Yes it does.

the cafe called, they want their straws back

yes what odds, were you expecting me to place a bet without first checking what i would win?

If i can get better odds at the bookies, i would obviously place it there

so whenever you make a comment which you are certain will happen, you needs odds attached to it?

you are odd!