Straight forward questions

If the game had not been on TV would you A) Know that's Cookes try was dubious?
B) Have given a try as you had observed it at normal speed?
C) Know that Hulls disallowed try was for offside at normal speed?

That's the trouble with the Video ref system, it's trying to achieve "perfection" in a sport where it is impossible to achieve because of so many variables.

D) have allowed Aaron Murphy's try

Its getting abit ridiculous with the ptb now, when we played kr earlier in the season the ref actually asked the video ref to check if the play off the ball was correct leading upto the try, the ptb wasnt correct but the try was awarded anyway. The the next game we played we got a penalty for incorrect ptb when we near the opposition line.

There is absolutly no consistancy.

Yep

Agreed

Applies to players, coaches, fans etc

rightly slaughtered by his own fans on the saints board for making a disgusting tasteless post from an incident that happened at the kc recently

the guy is a 1st class c0ck and should've been banned from these boards!

Not like you eh leaguefan same broken record as always.

I want to know why people think Cooke's try should have been disallowed? Cooke was holding the ball close to his body, not reaching out to put it down but holding the ball as he should be. Manu reaches around Cooke and places his hand on the ball, the ball comes free in a 1 on 1 tackle then Cooke lands on the ball in the in goal area which in my rule book is a try.

I too was a bit perplexed at first with the offside call against Yeaman as he was making an attempt to get back on side but as it has since been stated if he is offside at the ptb he isn't onside until the next play.

Hull were poor against Wakey but then Wakey were poor against Rovers so week to week you dont know which teams are going to turn up. The derby should be interesting because Rovers are full of confidence yet Hull are out to prove they are better than what they showed on Saturday.

Agree with you Matty, in our set of 6 from that pen Rich Moore (if i remember right) played ball in exactly same way Tansey had, but played on and we scored just after.
Yeaman try was disallowed for him being offside- in frony of ptb, but technically could have been disallowed for incorrect ptb.
The games a joke when 3/4 through season they decide to tighten up on 1 thing.

You missed the bit out where Manu's hand was still on the ball as it was grounded, before Cooke dropped on it, therefore it should have been a drop out.

It was certainly the most boring first half of rugby league shown by sky this season..and the second half was only marginally better.

If both attacker and defender ground it at the same time it's a try. To me it was Cooke's body and Manu's hand at the same time.

So Manu knocked it out his hands but Cooke's body was still touching it? When Manu knocked it out Cooke's hand, he also grounded it, Cooke's body dropped on it a split second after, re-watch it again and you'll see what happened.