Gildart was binned for rubbing a head, disgraceful they got away with it tonight. Should have been a bin.

We did, a bit more luck and it would have been closer, worry for me is that all chances came from kicks, although that's a credit to your defence.

I thought it was pretty tame in that respect, only a head pat and a shoulder charge from Singleton.

Correct. I only understand English, so I really struggle with that site

First half was pretty full on (mostly legal), definitely had the better first 25 minutes after which just then fell away.

Dirty Wigan s

I’ve seen the replay of the Smith try and didn’t see a forward pass. The Hastings one to Burgess is the one I presume you’re talking about but it looks fine to me. Even the man with a hawk eye for any hint of an issue in Wigan’s play, Terry O’Connor, didn’t call it and that’s good enough for me (talk about making sure people don’t think your biased towards your ex club). The French one is a penalty all day, you cannot go in with your feet as somebody is gathering a ball. Had French been trying to dive on a loose ball to score a try in the in goal and somebody went in with the feet like that, it would be a penalty at least.

The Griffin one I agree, he got that wrong in regards to it being two on one, although you could make a case to say the ball went forward off Griffin anyway. Hardly a hanging offence when it comes to his performances over a period of time and I’ll harp back to that Wigan vs Saints game. It was a masterclass in reffing a big game and he was let down on the Greenwood incident by the video ref. That is the standard of refereeing I want to see in all games but especially big games. Every player being given the opportunity not to give penalties away by clear instruction and a game being allowed to flow at great pace.

This thread wont be complete until every decision in the game has been analysed will it?

Ok ill start at the very beginning, does anyone have any issues with the coin toss?

If not lets move on......

Was anyone offside from the initial kick off, should a penalty have been blown?

.................................

Ive started you off, feel free to carry on from there

Every Hull player besides Connor should have been sin binned for not taking the knee for Black lives matter.

Can recall when French dropped a kick through and legitimate penalty given against Sneyd for pushing Hardaker and Farimo running to the line. When did your French/Connor/Griffin incident happen? I will take a look at it.

Ball steal against Griffin was marginal.

Kendall was in the perfect position on the Hastings pass with the TJ a metre away. Not forward from my viewing.

A fair assessment

He doesn't

Have to agree with DaveK, there were some odd decisions, but Wigan deserved the win, simple as that, had Griffin not ran across the pitch to act like a child it could have been different, but he did what he did (which, unfortunately, some fellow FC fans probably think was funny), did it cost is the game, no.

Well done Wigan, but I do hope Catalans beat Saints tonight, and then win it at the KC, that would really mess with Donnyman's swede!

Ive seen much worse ref performances that didnt get their own thread on here.

Must be because everyone on this forum are " Grrrr Wigan"