We were watching a different game then...

If Ganson says that ball didnt touch Roby before Carvell regathered then he shouldnt video ref anymore. If another offence occured resulting in a play on after it hit Roby then fair enough!

(Take nowt from Carvell though, he played to the whistle and ran it in for the try of his life. )

Maybe eddie was right the RFL now do video ref decisions based on morality not fact

I was a retarded decision, i dont know how ganson could not see the ball being knowed on into roby two if not three times

Althouigh it was ganson so maybe he does not know the rules after all

"Technically a knock on, but morally it should be a try"

What???

A low point in commentating history, surely.

Bit harsh on yourself there pal perhaps?

But I agree with your post. Do they still do that 'ask Cummings' thing on Boots n All (Not watched it in years)? It would be good to get a referee's viewpoint/justification for that.

We watched it with a Wire fan or three and they weren't getting excited even when Carvell was on his crazed dash, they all spotted it in real time and were convinced when they replayed it. One of the replays in particular had the knock on count about on par with the scoreline at the time. The correct decision was a knock on against Roby and a scrum to Warrington.

As it was Ganson - maybe he was drunk?

Totally cringeworthy comment, time for Wiggy to hang up his mic.

He fully deserved the try in my opinion and it would have been a travesty if it was not given for whats was impossible to see which direction the ball was travelling and who it was hitting.

Reward brilliance, not pedantic rule followers.

Forget the decision, where did Carvell get that pace from!!!

Get a drugs test on him, he was lightning!

Yes, a shocking decision. The fact that the ref referred suggested he felt there was a problem. Having viewed it he was correct. How anyone could give a try (as good a run as it was from Carvell) mystifies me.

Apart from the fact that Carvell was facing the Saints line throughout? Silverwood had seen it but wanted to double check. I'm convinced Ganson just stumbled onto the wrong button in a drunken lunge at the girl delivering him a beef sandwich.

Nice, now I have to mop up a mouthfull of Hoegaarden from my laptop keyboard.

PMSL - allegedly