What about when Carvell went over and Ganson said the tackle had been completed? At no time did Ganson call that tackle complete. He didn't on the radio ear piece at the ground (how cool are they?) and still hasn't on three watches, several rewinds and slow-mo!



The King no try, I agree with the decision but we all know we have seen them given at other times.

Its interesting to see how some of you view the game and how completly wrong you are with your assesments.


On the coaching side, Nathan Brown is so far ahead of Tony Smith in coaching terms that Smith is not fit to be an assistant trainer on Browns coaching staff.


Brown has Huddersfield looking, get this, like a fully fit Rugby League team. Shock horror!

He has tried to keep the game plan simple and put the team in the hands of Hodges and Fulton as much as he possibly can.

The Giants look for field position, repeat sets, they tackle more effectivly than other teams......

Brown is doing so well with what he has got, he is the class of all the SL coaches by a very long way.



As for the overall quality of the game....my god. It was f*cking horrific.

The blunders, the amateur stupidity, the lack of any feeling for the game. The poor defensive reads on just about every single play, the lack of line speed in the defenmse, the terrible kicking game, the non existant positional play by the Wolves fullbacks....I could go on and on!

To think that this is where SL is at in 2009, the British game is dying so quickly and I can not believe the lot of you are not up in arms and calling for the RFL to do something to save the sport.


IF people are right and imports will become less in SL, with fewer incentives, fewer rosters spots for them and tighter visa restrictions, SL is facing a period where it will be a competition full of completely inept players who are only able to compete because of their titally inept opposition.


There are basic things within the game that English players just have no understanding of at all. Things that an under 9's player in Australia or New Zealand would be ashamed of getting wrong.


The British game is dying and I tell you what, you have about 5 years before the damage is completely irreversable and you just can all sit back and watch SL fade into a feeder league for the RFU and their pathetic footballers.

That's about as far as I got. Do you drink?

Great turn out by the Wire fans but the Huddersfield turn out was again poor and contributed to a low attendance.

They also failed to get behind their team. 51 minutes before the 1st chant of "Fartown" and 3 mins later "Huddersfield". The fans were as poor as their team.

Oh....do you think I post here for you.

Oh.....I have some really bad news for you I'm afraid.....

Are you on the rag or something?


Who gives a sh*t about their turn out or how much "chanting" they did. Its a game of footy!

Your tests came back positive?

Someone teach him how to use the quote feature!

always attacking the poster but not the subject

Like what?

I assume from your posts you are in fact a coaching prodigy? Please, share your knowledge with us so we may drag SL to your wondrous level.

What basic things do English players have no understanding of?

all media down here say the same thing. the ref was half a metre away . unobstructed veiw. and he went to the video ref . he is a f--king joke .how pathetic. our jaw hit the ground with that 1

Thank you for your considered and intelligent response.

Attendances at Cup Finals/Grand Finals and 'big' weekly games have always been of interest both in the UK and Australia.

The sight of many empty seats did not look good and it is disappointing that after a good season to date the Huddersfield public did not turn out in their droves.

Unlike in Australia, fans in the UK tend to get behind there teams more vocally---as expressed by many, if not all, players from Down Under, and therefore it was surprising that the Huddersfield end of the ground--which I was in--was very quiet, even at the start of the game.

Yes, "its a game of footy" but other factors make the occasion.