God I hope not. Would be disastrous for the sport if they pulled out.

Why would it ?

because it would create a space for one of the failing English heartland clubs to fill. Would probably save Cas or wakey from going into NL1

Catalans are one of the most vibrant and exciting elements to Super League. Take them away and it would look very M62 and very, very dull.

SL needs a strong Catalans. If they are in trouble, the RFL should fund them. They should also consider taxing the other franchises in order to fund the Dragons to the level where they can win SL.

nuff said

Catalans replaced by Toulouse? Just a thought.

Non!

Wakefield, Salford and Cas replaced by Toulouse, Paris and Palma would be better.

and again

whys that then FRIEND??? is it because heartland clubs with rugby league history are been blatently ignored??? id rather have Widnes, Halifax and Leigh to your choices

Because that worked so well the last time they were all in Super League didn't it.

The sport needs to make a decision. If we want 4,000 crowds, whippets, by-ecky-thumping down the M62 corridor then fine. If we want a colourful, dynamic, exciting sport, that is in some way 'Super' we need to think bigger than we are at the moment.

if you want to watch a game that plays all across europe go watch kick and clap

Barry McKenzie will try and keep this argument simple.

Rugby League is not popular enough anywhere else apart from the 'North' of England, PNG and up the East Coast of Australia to catch on to the extent where a club can have any real commercial success out side of these areas.

So don't try.

Make the sport stronger where it is popular first and then MAYBE, just maybe try expanding.

But not before.



This is how Germany lost Operation Barbarossa in WW2.

Too much too soon too fast.

and for only the second time i agree with barry

What was the first time?


The Golden Point being brought into Superleague?

Paul Gallen is the best second Rower in the world?

Adrian Moreley couldnt keep his high shots down so was sent home by the Roosters?

Eliss and Burgess are decidedly average in the NRL?

VB is the best beer in the world?

Heavyweight cotton footy jumpers are far superior to the 'cheap' ISC polyester ones that feel like a cheap pair of kiddies jamjams?