I've never seen Sinfield do any of those things in a Test. Not one, I don't think, though i'll issue benefit of doubt for a sideline conversion.

Sinfield has never been given a run in the team thats why, 1 poor game and he would be dropped. Smith needs to pick his core players and stick with them to give them game time together.

Reckon Peacock will do 80 in second row or Crabtree come on at second row with Peacock shifting to prop?

Yeah i think maybe Ellis to do 80. When Burgess and Crabtree come on (probably together) for Graham and Morley i think Peacock will move upto prop with Crabtree with ellis and burgess in backrow.

Where do you think he's gunna bring Eastmond on?

The threequarters are the poorest I've seen in over fifty years to represent our country

I'm glad Tomkins has been given a run on his home ground i'm sure Smith will have told him to play his natural game.
McGuire and Sinfields last chance for me at international level, both good Super League players but dont perform at a higher level their field kicking, in the past, has been absymal! they have got to run Slater about with short then long kicks otherwise it'll be ................... ops!

its ok saying that but their is no one better at the moment. I disagree that they dnt perform, last year at world cup it was a whole squad thing but i still think mcguire was one of our better players and the year before that when we beat kiwis in the test series he played very well so dnt really know where you get your view from.

Sinfield needs a run of games with the same halfs, youve got no chance if these lads arnt given a bit of time to gel together, they need to build an understanding and changing a team (especially half backs) every game is not helping anybody. It would have made sense to pick the Leeds 6,7,13 combination.

He made himself available for selection again before the sqaud was picked, tony smith simply decided not to pick him.

I've been a big fan of gleeson over the years but he didnt perform in the world cup (admittadley he was nowhere near the worst offender) and has had his worst season that i can remember. I'd say smith was right not to pick him, it might just give the kick up the a*se he needs to bring his game back up to its former level and give us some more options for centre next year.

apparently senior did'nt get in touch with tony smith himself to tell him he came out of retirement...

Yeah i heard that, surely its up to Smith though to ask the player, Keith probably just didn't want to blow his own trumpet to much and take selection for granted, he was making enough noises to suggest that if the call came he would have played!

keith has blown his own trump, if he wanted to play he should have made that clear to the coach...not gone to the press and said "if you want me come and ask me"


it's that kind of attitude that cocked our world cup up...we're a team not a group of individuals

Disagree, Its down to the coach.