If we're going to talk about penalising every infringement then Peacock would have to stop running onto forward passes every time he takes the ball up, he'll have to stop punching blokes half his size and also stop abusing the referee and calling him a cheat.

Out of interest, when did Hill pick up that dubious finger in the eye injury?

Peacock and Hill have both had great seasons but Clark just pips them so far imo .

Who was the last player to win mos and younge player of the year in the same year ? If any

One things pretty obvious, a finger couldn't have caused the injury. That is, unless there was a Leeds player with a finger made of titanium. Come on, give it a little thought.

Clark by a mile, has been consistent in every game and simply devastating at times.

Why does it prove SL is weak?



My obvious bias? That being saying Clark could win it and be deserved? Thats bias?

Consequences? Like what? You're seriously implying that it wouldn't be right to award the MOS to an older player over a young new talent?
Its the best player during the course of the season, no ifs, no but, no age factors. Simple as that. And imo its still yet to be decided between Clark and JP.

Put your blouse back on and quit whinging.

Ha Ha Whinos you've got to love em, then again, no you don't!

And we love it. Dirty Leeds.

Think you may have to be locked away in a darkened room to calm down if we lift the trophy a week today. Nurse with sedative stand by.

Daryl Clark.

kevin brown for me

I'm going to put my hand up for James Roby.
His club's finished top of the pile and we've had a lot of injury problems in the other pivot positions. At times he's looked exhausted, but continued to play 80 minutes every week.

1054 Tackles Made (top of the pops), including a whopping 65 in the last game against Hudds.
7 Tries and 20 try assists.
2980 metres made.

His value to Saints is immeasurable and they're (until the play offs) number 1. He's just been given their player of the year.

If it isn't Darryl Clark there's something seriously wrong with the game..the lads being immense.

Sure, he would be a worthy winner.But lets not exaggerate, JP,Hill or Clark have all got an equal case for winning. It must be tight

Brown Shenton Roby have been excellent

Clark has been great but is nailed on to win Young Player I think.

So between Chris Hill and Jamie Peacock. Either would deserve it whichever wins. I think Hill is amazing!but that's my Wire bias calling that.