When he's on, Brough is the best half back we have available for selection. I'd rather have him and slightly inconsistent than a dull option like Wilkin.

Sinfield in for his kicking, only, very overrated in normal play, but Brough's not a good enough player or kicker.

Brough over Widdop? And then 2 players playing in positions they havn't played in for about 4 years.

Not for me thanks.

I thought this thread was going to be about who had the biggest forehead.

yet again, brough showed sinfield a masterclass in half back play
yet again sinfield was anonymous as the giants tore his team to shreds.
at the moment we have leeds' number and the so called best player in the world and his champion team have no answer to us.

Sinfield is a top man for Leeds and an excellent club captain but, he aint the best player in the world.
Although he is Leeds most important player.
Huddersfield were excellent yesterday, fully deserving the win.

that's just what I said to a leeds fan after the game.
I appreciate that he is a good player for what he does for leeds etc but as a RL fan I just don't see how sinfield is a world class player. to be fair I only see him when he plays against us or on tv but I can't remember seeing him have a good game at all this year, he,like his team only seems to be good when it matters in one off big games and even then its more to do with his leadership qualities rather than what he does with the ball.
yesterday I only noticed him really when he kicked out on the full, true world class players turn it on at some point during a game, sinfield doesn't for me.

Where was Sinfields kicking yesterda? I actually think Brough is a better kicker as he showed yesterday yet again.

I don't see Sinfield every game, but the sky games I've seen I haven't really noticed him. I wouldn't even say he has kicked well all season.

Leeds fans will say come play off team Sinfield will kick on, but it's the Leeds team in general that kick on, they get momentum and everyone starts playing well. This allows Sinfield to kick to the corner. But what about when things aren't going well, we need out stand off to stand up and put in a relieving kick. Brough did this numerous times yesterday for Hudds. Sinfield just didn't show up again.

If Brough carries it on for the rest of the season then I have no problem with him being picked ahead of Sinfield. I like the fact he looks like a cocky little git and on form he's got a genuinely dangerous short kicking game. Sadly, recent history suggests he and Huddersfield are far more likely to vanish without trace before the end of the year.

If the World Cup was in April, Danny Brough would be an automatic selection.

Enjoy him, Giants fans. You've got about another six weeks until your season falls apart, based on recent evidence.

And yet again Brough will probably end the year without any trophy s or success. Strange that eh?

and yet again, a players ability should not be judged on how many trophies his team have won.
brough at the moment is a better player than sinfield, who didn't want to know yesterday when the chips were down for his team.
im pretty sure players are judged on their individual skills rather than how many medals they have won?

recent as in years or weeks?
last year I think most people know the reason it fell apart, this year time will tell but we seem a much stronger and closer unit than this time last year.

Im sure when Sinfield retires and looks back on his career, he will think, I've had a good un, just wish I was as good as Danny Brough though

Yeah he'll think "if only I was as good a player, fortunately I had a team designed to do nothing but make me look better than I am"

Brough looks good on his own merits
Sinfield looks good on the back of others efforts