Got to be Roby; tough as teak, machine like reliability and importantly, goes about his business in a dignified and sportsmanlike manner.

Steve Menzies without a doubt.

When was the last time a player from a team finished outside the top 4 won MOS, nevermind from 6th?

That bald fella for Cas perhaps?

I’m surprised we don’t have a fully fledge RLFANS end of year award. Anyone fancy putting it together?

Turned out for the Exiles though as an Aussie.

A true Man of Steel besides being a very good player and influential, should show great sportmanship, honesty and respect to the opposition and be an ambassador to the game.

Unfortunately Tomkins dosn,t quite fit most of these parameters, the likes of Menzies and Roby do in bucketloads.

I wonder how James Graham won it then...

Who has won players player for what ever SL team you support, we'll get them all together and vote on it in a seperate thread

Warrington's is Mick Monaghan

By not being Vomkinsesque in 2008.

Sculthorpe, Farrell, Peacock, Graham, Roby, Lyon................................................................................................................................................... T(V)omkins should not be associated with this previous lot, unless we are letting standards slip.

Explain this then:

In 2000 we didn't know he'd turn out to be a gambling, drunk resident of Dale Farm.